Forum/Fishing Reports/Captain's Table - Scup Finally Take Off!

Captain's Table - Scup Finally Take Off!

521 views·13 replies·by captmike28
captmike28
captmike28FREE2024#1
Although I have been finding enough quality Scup to keep my customers satisfied this spring, up until today it required a lot of work and heavy chumming, This afternoons charter restored my faith in our typically excellent Peconic Porgy run.

For the first time in 21 years of running charters I had a group of 4 Amish fellows along with their driver/assistant, John, join me. These guys were serious about feeding their families as they drove all the way from Cooperstown (5 hours) to fish with me today. I had been told that they were all avid freshwater fisherman but had never dipped a line in the salt.

Sure enough these were very skilled anglers who handled the tackle masterfully and really wailed on the Porgies putting together a limit catch with no trouble in about 3 hours. Like last week we saw a number of real quality fish with several in the 3#+ range and many double headers.

The big excitement for the day came when Jacob ties into a fish that was obviously not a Scup. The fish took many long runs first to the bow, back to the stern, then amidships, but always digging for the bottom. So, while I thought it was a gator Blue I had hoped it might be something different. Sure enough after a very protracted battle I slip the net under a beautiful 30” Striped Bass. Amazing the tiny Porgy hook did not snap or pull out for all the pressure it sustained. I asked Jacob if this was the largest fish he ever caught but he modestly said no. He and his friends do take advantage of the Salmon run in Pulaski NY each year and they have landed some fish close to 40”. It is no wonder he did such a good job fighting that nice Bass on super light Scup tackle.

I hope the weather forecast for later this week settles down as I have Thurs, Fri, and Sat all booked. I also hope we can finally find some Weakfish as I know the upcoming crews have a desire to catch some of those beauties.

Capt. Mike

51324jacobbass.jpg51324groupbass.jpg
CaptainOriginal Crew1,847 postsSince 2018
Chinacat
ChinacatFREE2024#2
Although I have been finding enough quality Scup to keep my customers satisfied this spring, up until today it required a lot of work and heavy chumming, This afternoons charter restored my faith in our typically excellent Peconic Porgy run.

For the first time in 21 years of running charters I had a group of 4 Amish fellows along with their driver/assistant, John, join me. These guys were serious about feeding their families as they drove all the way from Cooperstown (5 hours) to fish with me today. I had been told that they were all avid freshwater fisherman but had never dipped a line in the salt.

Sure enough these were very skilled anglers who handled the tackle masterfully and really wailed on the Porgies putting together a limit catch with no trouble in about 3 hours. Like last week we saw a number of real quality fish with several in the 3#+ range and many double headers.

The big excitement for the day came when Jacob ties into a fish that was obviously not a Scup. The fish took many long runs first to the bow, back to the stern, then amidships, but always digging for the bottom. So, while I thought it was a gator Blue I had hoped it might be something different. Sure enough after a very protracted battle I slip the net under a beautiful 30” Striped Bass. Amazing the tiny Porgy hook did not snap or pull out for all the pressure it sustained. I asked Jacob if this was the largest fish he ever caught but he modestly said no. He and his friends do take advantage of the Salmon run in Pulaski NY each year and they have landed some fish close to 40”. It is no wonder he did such a good job fighting that nice Bass on super light Scup tackle.

I hope the weather forecast for later this week settles down as I have Thurs, Fri, and Sat all booked. I also hope we can finally find some Weakfish as I know the upcoming crews have a desire to catch some of those beauties.

Capt. Mike

View attachment 79880View attachment 79881
That is awesome Capt Mike! I’ve land keeper bass and big blues on fluke rigs but not a porgy rig
I’m very glad that trip worked out so great for you and the crew 👍👍
CommodoreOriginal Crew7,060 postsSince 2018
george
georgeADMIN2024#3
That's what fishing is all about: the thrill of the unknown and the surge of excitement when the unexpected happens.

Now I have to go fishing 😆
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,158 postsSince 2018
longcast
longcastFREE2024#4
Great trip Captain Mike!
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,411 postsSince 2019
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREE2024#5
Great report!

Thanks for sharing!
Captain4,156 postsSince 2021
Hunter704
Hunter704FREE2024#6
Well done Capt. Nice to see a change in the fish pattern and things are starting to gear up
CaptainOriginal Crew2,748 postsSince 2019
live bait
live baitFREE2024#7
Great job as usual Capt hope you don’t have to cut 140 porgies
CaptainOriginal Crew1,979 postsSince 2018
P
PangarooFREE2024#8
A lot of Amish up in Central NY, so many they have warning signs for Amish Buggies.See them in Walmart a lot. An Amish Buggy rode right in front of my property , very weird seeing that on a lonely upstate NY road surrounded by State Forest.The Amish love to hunt and fish.
First Mate701 postsSince 2021
P
PangarooFREE2024#9
Sheds Unlimited ??? The Amish came down and built a shed on my property about 10 years ago.
First Mate701 postsSince 2021
wader
waderFREE2024#10
>
Although I have been finding enough quality Scup to keep my customers satisfied this spring, up until today it required a lot of work and heavy chumming, This afternoons charter restored my faith in our typically excellent Peconic Porgy run.

For the first time in 21 years of running charters I had a group of 4 Amish fellows along with their driver/assistant, John, join me. These guys were serious about feeding their families as they drove all the way from Cooperstown (5 hours) to fish with me today. I had been told that they were all avid freshwater fisherman but had never dipped a line in the salt.

Sure enough these were very skilled anglers who handled the tackle masterfully and really wailed on the Porgies putting together a limit catch with no trouble in about 3 hours. Like last week we saw a number of real quality fish with several in the 3#+ range and many double headers.

The big excitement for the day came when Jacob ties into a fish that was obviously not a Scup. The fish took many long runs first to the bow, back to the stern, then amidships, but always digging for the bottom. So, while I thought it was a gator Blue I had hoped it might be something different. Sure enough after a very protracted battle I slip the net under a beautiful 30” Striped Bass. Amazing the tiny Porgy hook did not snap or pull out for all the pressure it sustained. I asked Jacob if this was the largest fish he ever caught but he modestly said no. He and his friends do take advantage of the Salmon run in Pulaski NY each year and they have landed some fish close to 40”. It is no wonder he did such a good job fighting that nice Bass on super light Scup tackle.

I hope the weather forecast for later this week settles down as I have Thurs, Fri, and Sat all booked. I also hope we can finally find some Weakfish as I know the upcoming crews have a desire to catch some of those beauties.

Capt. Mike

[ATTACH type="full" alt="51324jacobbass.jpg"]79880[/ATTACH][ATTACH type="full" alt="51324groupbass.jpg"]79881[/ATTACH]
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,900 postsSince 2018
wader
waderFREE2024#11
That's what fishing is all about: the thrill of the unknown and the surge of excitement when the unexpected happens.

Now I have to go fishing 😆
was fishing the Nissy from shore for flounder many, many, many years ago when my rig took off - had a bass double header on the line - made my day
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,900 postsSince 2018
captmike28
was fishing the Nissy from shore for flounder many, many, many years ago when my rig took off - had a bass double header on the line - made my day
Two Bass on a Flounder rod would probably make my decade!!🤣

Nicely done, Wader!
CaptainOriginal Crew1,847 postsSince 2018
captmike28
Great job as usual Capt hope you don’t have to cut 140 porgies
On all of my Porgy trips there is an agreement up front that while the anglers can take all the legal fish they want up to the bag limit I will only filet 20. That's about all my hands can stand!
CaptainOriginal Crew1,847 postsSince 2018
captmike28
That's what fishing is all about: the thrill of the unknown and the surge of excitement when the unexpected happens.

Now I have to go fishing 😆
You will, Geroge. Soon enough! However, I would not recommend trying a Porgy stick in the Gut!!!
CaptainOriginal Crew1,847 postsSince 2018
captmike28
That is awesome Capt Mike! I’ve land keeper bass and big blues on fluke rigs but not a porgy rig
I’m very glad that trip worked out so great for you and the crew 👍👍
Thanks, Mitch. I was working that very "secret spot" I showed you on shakedown day! 🤣
CaptainOriginal Crew1,847 postsSince 2018
Chinacat
ChinacatFREE2024#16
Thanks, Mitch. I was working that very "secret spot" I showed you on shakedown day! 🤣
I was kinda figuring that was the case😎
CommodoreOriginal Crew7,060 postsSince 2018

Sign in to reply to this thread.