Deer Butchers

I know of at least one on that list that will not be giving you back the same meat that you dropped off.
To some it doesn't matter, to others it may.
When in doubt, ask.

I know its not my guy Cary, so who is it ? Inquiring minds want to know ! (and then I will edit and remove the bum.)

Won't point fingers.
Just remember when general hunting season opens upstate. What ever they harvest comes back and a few on the island will handle all they can get. Their overwhelmed and hire butchers for that week or two. The cuts are packaged and labeled.
Your deer would have weighed when you first brought it in. You will get back so many pounds of each cut depending on that weight minus any shot damaged meat. Which would have been added into that equation.
Nothing new been that way for many years. Best bet is to ask before hand.

I think one of my shooting websites bought up the same thing. will see if they pointed fingers, lol. Most of my deer on a nuisance permit are taken before upstate gun season so Cary has only had one or two deer at a time when I have dropped mine off except once that I recall.