Forum/Fisheries Management/Maine proposing the cessation of a bait circle requirement for bass and blues.

Maine proposing the cessation of a bait circle requirement for bass and blues.

1,131 viewsยท8 repliesยทby Roccus7
Roccus7
Roccus7MOD2019#1
We've had a circle hook requirement in Maine for the past 5 years when using bait for bass and blues, although worm 'n tube was exempt, but no the DMR is looking to left the requirement. Here's the official bass Summary and notification of a public hearing in a week in BBH. Bluefish notification is the same with a "Find/Replace".

Still unsure how I feel about this since I really don't have a dog in this fight; I only drown mackerels/eels a few times a year. I always applauded Maine for taking an aggressive conservation stance, but felt cheated because ASMC never gave us credit for our efforts. At least now the State is taking a "we need to see a quid pro quo position" with ASMFC and I think that is laudable.



CHAPTER NUMBER AND TITLE: Chapter 42 Striped Bass Method of Taking
PROPOSED RULE NUMBER (leave blank; to be assigned by Secretary of State):
BRIEF SUMMARY:
This rule would remove the circle hook requirement for Atlantic striped bass. Due to their migratory behavior, the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC) governs interstate management for Atlantic striped bass. Consistent regulations across jurisdictions are recommended within the ASMFC Striped Bass Management Plan and a circle hook restriction is recommended within Amendment 6 of the Plan to reduce the mortality associated with hooking and releasing striped bass. Maine implemented a circle hook restriction in 2013 with the assumption that it be similarly implemented by the other Atlantic states. Other jurisdictions have not enacted this requirement and do not plan to implement a circle hook restriction. A circle hook restriction limited to Maine waters exclusively is not an effective management measure for a migratory fish species spanning from Maine to North Carolina along the Atlantic coast.
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,694 postsSince 2018
wader
waderFREE2019#2
Circle Hooks (weather mandated or not) should be used whenever fishing bait for the obvious reasons.
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,900 postsSince 2018
george
georgeADMIN2019#3
I'm opposed to any gear restrictions on tackle for rec anglers. Where do you draw the line? I am surprised that there was enough opposition to overturn the reg. NY anglers opted for one bass at 28-inches when they could have had two. We didn't get any credit either. We don't even get credit at all for Hudson River stripers either. They aren't even included in any of the modelings.

Please don't get me started on bluefish. While NMFS persuades us to "catch and release" they fail to tell you that the fish you're releasing is being added to the commercial quota. The rules are clear, we're allowed x amount of fish, and should we choose not to take them, NMFS transfers those fish to the commercial quota forever! I've called this out on dozens of occasions, but I feel like I'm the only one who cares about this blatant trasfer of quota from a traditional recreational fishery to a commercial fishery.

I've been told that the models don't allow us to "bank" fish. Of course they don't.
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,158 postsSince 2018
crabby
crabbyFREE2019#4
Circle Hooks (weather mandated or not) should be used whenever fishing bait for the obvious reasons.
For all species or just for bass?
CaptainOriginal Crew1,345 postsSince 2018
wader
waderFREE2019#5
All
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,900 postsSince 2018
Capt13
Capt13FREE2019#6
Scup too ?

๐Ÿค”
CaptainOriginal Crew2,530 postsSince 2018
crabby
crabbyFREE2019#7
All
I can't see them for all fish. I tried them for fluke and didn't like the hook-up ratio. I don't thin they would do well with tog either.
CaptainOriginal Crew1,345 postsSince 2018
MakoMike
MakoMikeFREE2019#8
They aren't even included in any of the modelings.

Are you sure about that? Up until I read that I was sure that the Hudson fish were included in the stock assessment.
First MateOriginal Crew710 postsSince 2018
george
georgeADMIN2019#9
Are you sure about that? Up until I read that I was sure that the Hudson fish were included in the stock assessment.
Hudson fish are not accounted for.
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,158 postsSince 2018

Sign in to reply to this thread.