Forum/Fishing Reports/Smithtown Bay

Smithtown Bay

81 views·14 replies·by george
george
georgeADMINJun 3#1
Hard to believe, but today was my first time out here in Smithtown Bay. I saw maybe two or three other boats. I marked no bait saw no birds and didn’t have a bite in three hours.

I tried for fluke on the incoming, but it was basically a dead sea.

I found water between 62 and 65° didn’t matter not a bite not a mark of bait anywhere. Hard to believe it’s the first week of June.

Wasn’t that long ago when we would be limiting on flute at this time. What is going on?
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,158 postsSince 2018
Snapprhead27
I think it's a late start all around. The cold weather hasn't helped.
Captain4,988 postsSince 2020
george
georgeADMINJun 4#3
Yeah, you guys got to face the reality of what's happening here. The fluke traditionally arrived here the first week of May. Now, every year it's getting pushed back, and they're scarcer. If there's no bait, there will be no fluke.
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,158 postsSince 2018
Snapprhead27
We had them spitting up sand eels and some had whole squid.
Captain4,988 postsSince 2020
longcast
longcastFREEJun 4#5
> **george, post: 345719, member: 2 wrote:**
> Yeah, you guys got to face the reality of what's happening here. The fluke traditionally arrived here the first week of May. Now, every year it's getting pushed back, and they're scarcer. If there's no bait, there will be no fluke.

A bit dated, but these feeds come up on Facebook all the time. Weather maybe forced them into a staging area and they got pounded.
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,411 postsSince 2019
Double Trouble
> **longcast, post: 345741, member: 288 wrote:**
>
>
> A bit dated, but these feeds come up on Facebook all the time. Weather maybe forced them into a staging area and they got pounded.

Ya but the rod and reel guys are killing the fishing.
First MateOriginal Crew346 postsSince 2019
longcast
longcastFREEJun 4#7
> **Double Trouble, post: 345742, member: 248 wrote:**
> Ya but the rod and reel guys are killing the fishing.

How so?
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,411 postsSince 2019
Snapprhead27
> **longcast, post: 345743, member: 288 wrote:**
> How so?

Thinking he maybe using sarcasm, being the rec guys are always getting blamed when it comes to regulations.
Captain4,988 postsSince 2020
Double Trouble
> **Snapprhead27, post: 345745, member: 1443 wrote:**
> Thinking he maybe using sarcasm, being the rec guys are always getting blamed when it comes to regulations.

YEP
First MateOriginal Crew346 postsSince 2019
longcast
longcastFREEJun 5#10
> **Snapprhead27, post: 345745, member: 1443 wrote:**
> Thinking he maybe using sarcasm, being the rec guys are always getting blamed when it comes to regulations.

Never seen a rec cooler look like that.
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,411 postsSince 2019
Snapprhead27
Agreed
Captain4,988 postsSince 2020
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREEJun 5#12
Draggers hammered the fluke and scup all winter. Lack of fish is no coincidence...............
Captain4,156 postsSince 2021
pequa1
pequa1MODJun 6#13
Worst early season I have ever had. Paddling and drifting backbay I see no bait. Cormorants look sad. In 5 paddles I have one 18" fluke and yesterday what was probably a bite off by a blue. No cocktail blitz. Although I leave the hearing aids home, most guys I have conversed with, if they put up with me, have said much the same, and in motorboats they are hitting spots that I only used to fish. If this continues I will probably just paddle weekdays and work on pool and yard weekends.
CommodoreOriginal Crew7,027 postsSince 2018
hawk375
hawk375FREEJun 7#14
Hopefully the wether but probably not it is sad to see how people who have fished for so many years still blame rec and commercial for the current state of our fishing and no one mentions the fact that the only difference here is the ASMFC power all other areas of united state these interstate groups have no power
Mate117 postsSince 2020
F
Party boats are wiping out what few fish are there. On top of that I saw 2 trawlers working around the Lilco fueling station
MateOriginal Crew74 postsSince 2019

Sign in to reply to this thread.