New York City's reservoirs are a treasure trove for fishing enthusiasts, offering a wide variety of fish species. To fish in these reservoirs, you'll need an access permit from the NYC Department of Environmental Protection (DEP). Additionally, special permits are available for storing boats on the shoreline in designated areas. Some reservoirs also permit non-motorized recreational boating on a day-use basis.
For more information on permits and fishing spots, visit the NYC Environmental Protection Recreation website.
Warmwater Fish Species
The reservoirs offer excellent opportunities for catching warmwater fish. In reservoirs with stable water levels, warmwater species often thrive in submerged vegetation beds. In contrast, reservoirs with fluctuating water levels typically have less vegetation, and warmwater fish tend to seek shelter in shallow bottom structures like rock ledges and boulders. These fish are more accessible to shoreline anglers than their coldwater counterparts.
Smallmouth Bass
Smallmouth bass are a dominant warmwater predator in reservoirs with minimal vegetation. They primarily feed on crayfish and open water baitfish. Notable reservoirs for smallmouth bass include Bog Brook and New Croton, with some fish weighing over 6 pounds. The reservoirs west of the Hudson River are particularly renowned for smallmouth bass fishing, with Ashokan Reservoir being a standout for both the number and size of fish.
Largemouth Bass
Largemouth bass are plentiful in the vegetated reservoirs east of the Hudson River. Titicus and Croton Falls reservoirs have yielded bass over 8 pounds. Due to boating restrictions, these reservoirs are less heavily fished, allowing bass to grow larger. Shore fishing is especially successful during the spring catch-and-release season when bass are in shallower waters.
Pickerel and Tiger Muskellunge
The vegetated shallows of these reservoirs are also home to chain pickerel and tiger muskellunge. While pickerel are not as abundant as largemouth bass, they offer an exciting fishing experience. Muscoot Reservoir, for instance, has produced pickerel up to 6 pounds. Tiger muskies have been stocked in Middle Branch Reservoir since 2003, with some exceeding 40 inches in length.
Walleye
Several NYC reservoirs have successfully introduced walleye. Boyds Corners Reservoir, for example, was stocked with walleye fry in the early 1990s, leading to a self-sustaining population. These fish have also created a walleye fishery in West Branch Reservoir. Titicus Reservoir has been recently stocked, with hopes of establishing a robust walleye population. Walleye fisheries have also emerged in East Branch, Diverting, and Bog Brook reservoirs, with some catches weighing up to 11 pounds.
Perch and Crappie
NYC reservoirs have seen near state record-size catches of white perch and crappie. In recent years, crappie exceeding 3 pounds have been caught in New Croton, Middle Branch, and Cross River reservoirs. These reservoirs have also produced large white perch, with some nearing 3 pounds. Yellow perch are common in all NYC reservoirs, with larger specimens caught in Titicus, Kensico, and Croton Falls reservoirs.
Common Carp
Common carp, some weighing over 20 pounds, are found in many NYC reservoirs. Carp fishing, including bowfishing, is a popular activity, especially from May to August.
Coldwater Fish Species
NYC reservoirs are also home to coldwater species like brown, rainbow, and lake trout, as well as landlocked Atlantic salmon. These species rely on cool, well-oxygenated water and are usually found in deeper parts of the reservoirs during summer. Browns, rainbows, and landlocks prefer temperatures in the 55º-60º range, while lake trout favor cooler waters.
Brown Trout and Landlocked Atlantic Salmon
Brown trout are a primary species in NYC reservoirs, with many caught in the 8 to 10-pound range. Some of the largest brown trout come from Kensico, Rondout, and Pepacton reservoirs. Shore fishing near deep water or moving water sources can be particularly fruitful. Landlocked Atlantic salmon are stocked in West Branch and Neversink reservoirs, offering a unique fishing experience.
Rainbow Trout
Ashokan Reservoir is renowned for its rainbow trout, with a naturally reproducing population. The mouth of Esopus Creek and the midpoint of the reservoir are prime spots for catching rainbows. Muscoot Reservoir is also known for producing sizable rainbow trout.
Lake Trout
Lake trout, or lakers, are typically found in the deeper, colder parts of the reservoirs. They can grow quite large, with some reaching 20 pounds. Rondout and Kensico reservoirs are known for their lake trout populations. Ice fishing in Lakes Gleneida and Gilead can also yield impressive catches.
Ice Fishing Opportunities
Thirteen reservoirs east of the Hudson River permit ice fishing, providing year-round fishing opportunities for both warm and coldwater species.
Fishing Regulations
Be sure to check the Special Fishing Regulations for NYC reservoirs and lakes, as many have specific rules and guidelines.