noreaster.com
Forum/General Discussion/Say Good Bye To Catch and Release Striped Bass Fishing

Say Good Bye To Catch and Release Striped Bass Fishing

2,198 views·21 replies·by george·First Post·Latest
george
georgeADMINnoreaster.com2024#21
Here’s the real story on how the Catch and Release (C&R) testing was conducted. First off, let’s set the record straight—it wasn’t in ’96; the actual tests took place in 1989. I’ve pulled these facts straight from the study, which I’ve attached for your review.

Here’s how it went down: the fish were caught using haul seines and then tossed into a truck for a grueling 5-hour ride. After that, they were crammed into a smaller tank for a bit before being tagged and released into a 5,000-acre pond in Massachusetts. This pond, averaging just 4 feet deep and sitting at around 80 degrees, was hardly ideal. After feeding them for a while, they were targeted again—this time using traditional fishing techniques from the late '80s.

Honestly, I’m surprised any of those fish survived at all. Think about it—they were taken from the ocean, thrown into a truck for five hours, transferred to another tank, and then released into completely unfamiliar waters. And this is the study that’s being used to justify keeping us tied to the docks, imposing draconian measures that threaten our fishing future. We’re talking about a fishery that supports 10 million angler trips, all of whom deserve better.

We can’t just sit back and let this destroy our enjoyment and livelihoods.

Heres a recap

Location and Environment
  • The study was carried out in a 2-hectare saltwater pond at the Massachusetts Division of Marine Fisheries Cat Cove Marine Laboratory in Salem, Massachusetts. The pond is a dammed inlet with an average depth of approximately 3 meters, reaching a maximum depth of 4.5 meters. It is not subject to tidal fluctuations but can be partially drained via sluice gates.
  • Environmental conditions during the study included stable salinity (31 ppt) and pH (7.0), with surface water temperatures ranging from 15 to 28°C and bottom temperatures never exceeding 25°C. Dissolved oxygen levels varied from 6.0 to 9.0 mL/L at the surface and 3.8 to 8.4 mL/L at the bottom.
Fish Acquisition and Acclimation
  • Striped bass were sourced from a trap-net operator in Newport, Rhode Island. Three fish traps were set within 3 km of shore and tended daily over a 20-day period. The fish were transported in a 760-liter holding tank with running seawater and tagged with uniquely coded Floy internal anchor tags during the trip to shore.
  • The fish were then transferred to a 1,900-liter circular tank on a truck for delivery to the study site, with transfer time averaging 5 hours. Five batches of approximately 200 fish each were delivered between April 22 and April 28, 1989, with an additional delivery of 17 fish on June 13, bringing the total to 1,015 tagged fish released into the pond.
  • To estimate mortality from tagging and transport, the first and last batches of fish were held in a net-pen in the pond for 24 hours and 5 days, respectively, before being released into the pond. The net-pen was 3 meters long, 5 meters wide, and 2 meters deep, constructed of 2.5-cm mesh nylon netting.
  • The fish were given a 50-day acclimation period in the pond before the hooking experiment began, allowing them to adjust to the environment.
Feeding and Health Monitoring
  • Indigenous populations of finfish and invertebrates in the pond, such as fourspine stickleback, Atlantic silverside, mummichog, mysid shrimp, and sand shrimp, provided a natural food source for the striped bass.
  • Control fish were captured from the pond using gill-nets and held in a net-pen, where they were fed dead American sand lances and monitored for mortality throughout the study period.
George R. Scocca
george@nyangler.com
www.nyangler.com - Your Secret Spot Online !
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,174 postsSince 2018
Roccus7
Roccus7MODnoreaster.com2024#22
Once again, to date it's the only game in town. Without that I bet NOAA/ASMFC would have gone with their normal 50% mortality guesstimation. I do look forward to the results from the latest study; it will be nice to have an accurate number on 1 aspect of striped bass.

Regardless, since we all agree Garbage In=Garbage Out, until we can get reasonably accurate information as to how many bass are actually caught, released and retained, whatever mortality factor is used is almost a non-issue. IMO, accurate catch and harvest numbers are the most important numbers, and are key in every aspect of recreational striped bass management.
Shall I go to heaven or a-fishing? - H. D. Thoreau
Veni. Vidi. Cepi. - with apologies to Gaius Julius Caesar
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,717 postsSince 2018

Sign in to reply to this thread.

Thread
Say Good Bye To Catch and Release Striped Bass Fishing
Sign in