noreaster.com
Forum/Fisheries Management/Fluke, sea bass and scup

Fluke, sea bass and scup

8,621 views·83 replies·by MakoMike·First Post·Latest
Bassmaster
When it was 14 I never kept them there was not much filets on them. I had several 17 to 18 and 3 quarter inch fluke last year.
CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
BoatGuy
BoatGuynoreaster.com2022#62
from what you're saying when NJ Sea bass season is open and ny is closed they can fish in New York waters and keep bass.
That makes no sense. Even if you fished NJ waters and kept fish legally, when you reentered NY waters, if you were boarded you would have illegal fish.

I'm so confused.
First MateOriginal Crew780 postsSince 2019
Bassmaster
It seems like they want to put party boat captains out of business. That is the impression I am getting. Just make it one regulation for new York NJ Connecticut and Rhode island. Absolute stupidity.
CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
Leprechaun
LeprechaunMODnoreaster.com2022#64
Here's a couple of real nice biscuits taken on Capt. Mike's boat during the Spring Porgy run - both went back - which about killed me. We caught MANY such fish that day. You can bet your last GULP! grub that the Conn. boats fishing deep in the Peconics ain't throwin' those fish back.

5.14.2016 Jessups3.JPG
"Luck" is when preparation meets opportunity.
I prefer fishing evolution to fishing extinction.
If ya want to clean up the water, ya gotta get the pigs out of the creek.
CaptainOriginal Crew2,216 postsSince 2018
Roccus7
Roccus7MODnoreaster.com2022#65
Here's a couple of real nice biscuits taken on Capt. Mike's boat during the Spring Porgy run - both went back - which about killed me. We caught MANY such fish that day. You can bet your last GULP! grub that the Conn. boats fishing deep in the Peconics ain't throwin' those fish back.

View attachment 46077
DEC should board out of state boats during misaligned seasons...
Shall I go to heaven or a-fishing? - H. D. Thoreau
Veni. Vidi. Cepi. - with apologies to Gaius Julius Caesar
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,717 postsSince 2018
pequa1
pequa1MODnoreaster.com2022#66
Or the effing states should agree on effing dates
Every day is Saturday.
CommodoreOriginal Crew7,034 postsSince 2018
Leprechaun
LeprechaunMODnoreaster.com2022#67
As Pequa1 said, above!
"Luck" is when preparation meets opportunity.
I prefer fishing evolution to fishing extinction.
If ya want to clean up the water, ya gotta get the pigs out of the creek.
CaptainOriginal Crew2,216 postsSince 2018
Leprechaun
LeprechaunMODnoreaster.com2022#68
Does this remind anyone of our Fisheries Management dysfunctionality?


Dilbert does Fisheries Mgmt_edited.webp
"Luck" is when preparation meets opportunity.
I prefer fishing evolution to fishing extinction.
If ya want to clean up the water, ya gotta get the pigs out of the creek.
CaptainOriginal Crew2,216 postsSince 2018
longcast
longcastFREE2022#69
Does this remind anyone of our Fisheries Management dysfunctionality?


View attachment 46372
Send that to their meetings as "Exhibit 1 " 🙄
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
Fluke Whisperer
Does this remind anyone of our Fisheries Management dysfunctionality?


View attachment 46372
This is so spot on and not just with marine fisheries.
First MateOriginal Crew508 postsSince 2019
Bassmaster
Fluke regs are out may 1st to Oct 9th 18.5 four fish
CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
BoatGuy
BoatGuynoreaster.com2022#72
Fluke regs are out May 1st to Oct 9th 18.5 four fish

My friend showed me something else. The NYSDEC website has not been updated yet.
First MateOriginal Crew780 postsSince 2019
pequa1
pequa1MODnoreaster.com2022#73
just b4 fluke opens !
Every day is Saturday.
CommodoreOriginal Crew7,034 postsSince 2018
hartattack
NJ considering slot for Fluke this year.
options
1) May 21 - Sep 23.... 3 fish @ 17.5 or greater
2) May 2 - Sep 27 .... 2 slots between 17 and 17.99 and 1 over 18
3) May 27 - Oct 2 ..... 2 slots between 16.5 and 17.99 and 1 over 18
4) May 1 - Sep 30 ..... 3 fish @ 18 or greater
5) May 24 - Sep 10 .... 1 slot between 16.5 and 17.99 and 2 over 18

See attached
Once in a while you can get shown the light
In the strangest of places if you look at it right
First MateOriginal Crew286 postsSince 2018
Roccus7
Roccus7MODnoreaster.com2022#75
NJ considering slot for Fluke this year.
options
1) May 21 - Sep 23.... 3 fish @ 17.5 or greater
2) May 2 - Sep 27 .... 2 slots between 17 and 17.99 and 1 over 18
3) May 27 - Oct 2 ..... 2 slots between 16.5 and 17.99 and 1 over 18
4) May 1 - Sep 30 ..... 3 fish @ 18 or greater
5) May 24 - Sep 10 .... 1 slot between 16.5 and 17.99 and 2 over 18

See attached
Classic NJ, "Gimme more!!!"
Shall I go to heaven or a-fishing? - H. D. Thoreau
Veni. Vidi. Cepi. - with apologies to Gaius Julius Caesar
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,717 postsSince 2018
pequa1
pequa1MODnoreaster.com2022#76
NY didn't officially announce until April 21 last year. I think some local tackle shop posted a week ago that the limit would be 5 fish at 18". Truly hope this is wrong. A bag of 5 will decimate the biomass especially when dropping the size. I can live with 3 or even 2 at 18" but would really like to see a slot.
Every day is Saturday.
CommodoreOriginal Crew7,034 postsSince 2018
hartattack
NJ has voted on and approved option 2:
May 2 - Sep 27 .... 2 slots between 17 and 17.99 and 1 over 18

Opinion: 2 fish to fit inside a 1" slot coupled with inevitable high grading for that single over 18 - could be recipe for trouble.... although the party boats will enjoy it...
Once in a while you can get shown the light
In the strangest of places if you look at it right
First MateOriginal Crew286 postsSince 2018
BoatGuy
BoatGuynoreaster.com2022#78
Classic NJ, "Gimme more!!!"

But they are smart. I went on a call and whomever was representing NJ had a kit when they wanted to cut there season by one day. Finally NY gave up one day so they could move on.

Now, with fish between 17 and 17.99 and 1 over 18, more people will fish. Shops sell more bait, more rigs and supplies with misc. tackle (rods and reels) and more boat rentals. People from NY go to NJ to fish.
First MateOriginal Crew780 postsSince 2019
Roccus7
Roccus7MODnoreaster.com2022#79
NJ has voted on and approved option 2:
May 2 - Sep 27 .... 2 slots between 17 and 17.99 and 1 over 18

Opinion: 2 fish to fit inside a 1" slot coupled with inevitable high grading for that single over 18 - could be recipe for trouble.... although the party boats will enjoy it...
Also a 1" slot is so very tight as to be ridiculous. That 17.0" fish ain't going to be 17.0 if it sits in the sun, along with an 18.0" fish going from over the slot, into the high end of the slot...
Shall I go to heaven or a-fishing? - H. D. Thoreau
Veni. Vidi. Cepi. - with apologies to Gaius Julius Caesar
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,717 postsSince 2018
pequa1
pequa1MODnoreaster.com2022#80
A 17 is about dinner for three (unless some of you are piggish) and only if that fish has been on bait. I do like the limit of just three though.
Every day is Saturday.
CommodoreOriginal Crew7,034 postsSince 2018

Sign in to reply to this thread.

Thread
Fluke, sea bass and scup
Sign in