According to Newsday, and with no spot burning:
"The former first mate of North Star, which operated fishing charters out of Captree Boat Basin, admitted in federal court Tuesday to helping to deliberately sink the vessel in off Long Island’s coast in 2018.
The guilty plea of Thomas Jordan, 57, of Brentwood, followed an indictment last year charging him and the vessel’s owner with crimes that included destroying North Star, conspiring to do so and lying to Coast Guard investigators about it.
Jordan and vessel owner Timothy Juettner, 53, allegedly sank the fishing vessel because it needed major repairs Juettner couldn’t afford, sources previously told Newsday.
On Oct. 8, 2018, the vessel went down in the Atlantic Ocean within 12 nautical miles of the coast, according to the 2020 indictment.
The ex-first mate told Magistrate Judge A. Kathleen Tomlinson on Tuesday while pleading guilty to one count of the indictment that he and another defendant worked together to destroy the vessel and he was at the scene when it sank.
The crime also involved using a second vessel as a towing aid, according to Jordan's admissions. He later declined to comment after leaving the Central Islip courtroom."
North Star
4,331 views·18 replies·by Matts
What a shame..the old north star from city island!!! A WORK HORSE
CommodoreOriginal Crew12,530 postsSince 2018
I guess Tim couldn’t hang on any longer. Crazy times man. I remember when he bought the boat from Pete. We used to dock right alongside the old girl. The decks of that baby had to see millions of fish over the years.
CommodoreOriginal Crew12,530 postsSince 2018
FAKE story.
You’re better half nailed the blackfish.
CommodoreOriginal Crew12,530 postsSince 2018
I'll see you saturday and you can cater to her while I whoop them flatties!!!! I want fresh sea robin strips when you get em
CommodoreOriginal Crew12,530 postsSince 2018
H
I guess Tim couldn’t hang on any longer. Crazy times man. I remember when he bought the boat from Pete. We used to dock right alongside the old girl. The decks of that baby had to see millions of fish over the years.
Deckhand1 postsSince 2022
Do you have any photos of that boat? I have been looking for the boat Flying Cloud from Montauk. I thought it was brought to Captree.
CommodoreOriginal Crew12,530 postsSince 2018
What a shame..the old north star from city island!!! A WORK HORSE
MateOriginal Crew241 postsSince 2019
We lived in the Bronx and I went on the North Star a lot as a kid. City Island was our version of Knapp St so to speak, but obviously on a lesser scale . The Apache was there too and the Ebb Tide later on . I’m sure I forgot a few more . That’s a shame, many fond memories on the North Star.
CommodoreOriginal Crew12,530 postsSince 2018
The Apache was the very first party boat I ever went on, but then became a North Star regular on Wednesdays.....the days of Milton running the galley...Jimmy DiCuffa and Mike "Irish" running the deck and Davey who eventually ran his own successful charter boat
That was also a treat as a kid before getting on the party boats my uncle would take me into Jack’s
MateOriginal Crew241 postsSince 2019
Is Pete down in the Keys with John DiCuffa’s mom ?
That was also a treat as a kid before getting on the party boats my uncle would take me into Jack’s
CommodoreOriginal Crew12,530 postsSince 2018
I guess Tim couldn’t hang on any longer. Crazy times man. I remember when he bought the boat from Pete. We used to dock right alongside the old girl. The decks of that baby had to see millions of fish over the years.
Deckhand1 postsSince 2025
Mackerel fishing in the late 70's was off the hook.
Boats from Sheepshead Bay would make the run up the east river to fish the western sound.
My dad and I used small tins and freshwater rods, loosened the drag, and those big Macks would take off like a tuna.
Too bad it never came back.
Boats from Sheepshead Bay would make the run up the east river to fish the western sound.
My dad and I used small tins and freshwater rods, loosened the drag, and those big Macks would take off like a tuna.
Too bad it never came back.
First MateOriginal Crew693 postsSince 2019
M
Mackerel fishing in the late 70's was off the hook.
Boats from Sheepshead Bay would make the run up the east river to fish the western sound.
My dad and I used small tins and freshwater rods, loosened the drag, and those big Macks would take off like a tuna.
Too bad it never came back.
DeckhandOriginal Crew32 postsSince 2019
Sign in to reply to this thread.
Thread
North Star