noreaster.com
Forum/Inshore Tackle & Techniques/Post your 2019-2025 Fluke Pix & Trip Reports Here!

Post your 2019-2025 Fluke Pix & Trip Reports Here!

156,661 views·1393 replies·by Leprechaun·First Post·Latest
george
georgeADMINnoreaster.com2025#1181
Now I'm hungry!

Back to the trip on Saturday. My hand is still cramping from all of the 2-3 pound fish we had to release. I know you hear the bitching and complaining about the regs all of the time, both here and all over the web. I decided to break down this trip and multiply our results to the 200 anglers total targeting fish and the party boats there. This is one eye opening stat I found here. This is proof that our fisheries managers don't have a clue. WE KILLED 3X THE AMOUNT OF FLUKE THEN WE KEEP! Had the limit been 18-inches, there would be about 1000 more fluke swimming around today. many of them over 2-pounds!

Here's a breakdown on the day:

For years, recreational anglers have been blamed for fluke declines. The reality on the water tells a different story.

One day fishing south of Jones Inlet:
Our boat had 3 anglers. We released 100 fluke, kept 4, and 11 died after release.
All party boats in the area: 290 anglers (five trips total). They released 7,250 fluke, kept 290, and 797 died after release.
Private boats: 200 more anglers. They released 7,000 fluke, kept 280, and 770 died after release.

Add it up:
Total anglers fishing that day—almost 500.
Total fluke released—14,350.
Total kept—574.
Total dead from release mortality—1,579.

That means for every fluke kept, nearly three died after release. Strict size limits mean anglers throw back thousands of fish, and many don’t survive. The numbers expose the truth: more fluke die from being tossed back than from being taken home.

The system is not working. Lowering the size limit would save more fish and reduce waste. That’s how you support both the fishery and the anglers who care about it most.
George R. Scocca
george@nyangler.com
www.nyangler.com - Your Secret Spot Online !
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,174 postsSince 2018
Chinacat
And in my opinion an 18-19” fluke is sweeter and tastier than one thats over 22-23”
At least I'm enjoyin' the ride.....
CommodoreOriginal Crew7,065 postsSince 2018
Matts
MattsFREE2025#1183
Now I'm hungry!

Back to the trip on Saturday. My hand is still cramping from all of the 2-3 pound fish and had to release. I know you hear the bitching and complaining about the regs all of the time, both here and all over the web. I decided to break down this trip and multiply our results to the 200 anglers total targeting fish and the party boats there. This is one eye opening stat I found here. This is proof that our fisheries managers don't have a clue. WE KILLED 3X THE AMOUNT OF FLUKE THEN WE KEEP! Had the limit been 18-inches, there would be about 1000 more fluke swimming around today. many of them over 2-pounds!

Here's a breakdown on the day:

For years, recreational anglers have been blamed for fluke declines. The reality on the water tells a different story.

One day fishing south of Jones Inlet:
Our boat had 3 anglers. We released 100 fluke, kept 4, and 11 died after release.
All party boats in the area: 290 anglers (five trips total). They released 7,250 fluke, kept 290, and 797 died after release.
Private boats: 200 more anglers. They released 7,000 fluke, kept 280, and 770 died after release.

Add it up:
Total anglers fishing that day—almost 500.
Total fluke released—14,350.
Total kept—574.
Total dead from release mortality—1,579.

That means for every fluke kept, nearly three died after release. Strict size limits mean anglers throw back thousands of fish, and many don’t survive. The numbers expose the truth: more fluke die from being tossed back than from being taken home.

The system is not working. Lowering the size limit would save more fish and reduce waste. That’s how you support both the fishery and the anglers who care about it most.
George
I don't quite follow your reasoning that a smaller size limit would reduce catch and release mortality or am I missing something.
It seems to me the only way to reduce catch and release mortality is to reduce catching, i.e., shortening the season, which no one wants.
Are you suggesting that if we lowered the size limit, anglers would catch their limit, and then stop fishing? I think most anglers would just switch to catch and release. some might even cull a dead fish for a new, bigger fish.
If I was on a party boat and caught my limit early in the trip, I'd be pretty pissed if they made me sit and watch for the rest of the trip; or if they headed in after a full boat limit was reached.
First MateOriginal Crew693 postsSince 2019
OVERBORED
George
I don't quite follow your reasoning that a smaller size limit would reduce catch and release mortality or am I missing something.
It seems to me the only way to reduce catch and release mortality is to reduce catching, i.e., shortening the season, which no one wants.
Are you suggesting that if we lowered the size limit, anglers would catch their limit, and then stop fishing? I think most anglers would just switch to catch and release. some might even cull a dead fish for a new, bigger fish.
If I was on a party boat and caught my limit early in the trip, I'd be pretty pissed if they made me sit and watch for the rest of the trip; or if they headed in after a full boat limit was reached.
Its what some boats in Alaska do when Halibut fishing. No C&R!
"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
george
georgeADMINnoreaster.com2025#1185
I’m
George
I don't quite follow your reasoning that a smaller size limit would reduce catch and release mortality or am I missing something.
Matt, you’re reading me right. A lower size limit reduces discard mortality because anglers reach a take-home bag with fewer handled fish. Fewer shorts in the net means fewer fish stressed, gut-hooked, or dying later.
It seems to me the only way to reduce catch and release mortality is to reduce catching, i.e., shortening the season, which no one wants.
“Just shorten the season” only tackles effort. Managers care about total mortality. If we can convert a pile of dead discards into a smaller pile of legal keepers with fewer releases, total mortality drops without chopping the calendar to bits.
Are you suggesting that if we lowered the size limit, anglers would catch their limit, and then stop fishing?
Have you ever been on a party boat playing catch and release for fluke? You would never do that on my boat. Not that the opportunity has shown itself recently 🙂
I think most anglers would just switch to catch and release. some might even cull a dead fish for a new, bigger fish.
Again you wouldn't be doing that on my boat. And I personally have rarely seen it happen on parry or charter boats. There's always something else to move on to.
If I was on a party boat and caught my limit early in the trip, I'd be pretty pissed if they made me sit and watch for the rest of the trip; or if they headed in after a full boat limit was reached.
If that were the case wouldn't that be true today? Have you ever seen anyone on a party boat catch their limit and stop fishing?
George R. Scocca
george@nyangler.com
www.nyangler.com - Your Secret Spot Online !
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,174 postsSince 2018
Leprechaun
LeprechaunMODnoreaster.com2025#1186
(Also posted this on the "General" board for those that do not read this board)

So here are the variables as I see them:

1/ No accurate counting of private boats (or rec fishermen)

2/ No accurate accounting of days fished by each rec

3/ Keeping short fish? I know for a fact that several charter boats in my area allow the keeping/fast cutting of "close enough" sub-legal fish, so that their fares "go home with something." Obviously no numbers of that catch quantity. (I know this because it came right out of the mouth of some charter captains that I know). Also, we see what goes back in the water from the decks of party boats that fish right next to us. Obvious cheating.

4/ Variable catch results boat to boat/man to man.

5/ I know charter boats must fill out a trip report. Anyone ever check the veracity of those reports? How often?

6/ Boats fishing "NY-area grounds" from NJ. We throw back sub-19" fish (19.5" fish now). NJ boats fishing right next to us put those fish right in their boxes - and sail back to NJ. All legal as most of this fishing occurs outside NYS waters (Federal), but creates an obvious skewing of the NY landings

7/ Right out of a draggerman's mouth while I was at Mark Flynn's old shop - NY boats drag to the West in the morning, land their fish in NJ (illegally? Maybe, I don't know), then drag the same exact trawl line back to the East and land those fish in NY (also probably now illegally). According to him, the fluke will swim to the drag-disturbed bottom to feed on whatever the drag net stirred up. Those fish get caught up on the return trawl. GPS track plotters are the devil's doing. 😛

8/ Every now and then a dragger gets bagged for illegal catch quantities. Those reports are few and far between. As I see it, no real accounting for whatever other boats are doing this. I suppose insufficient personnel to properly police this practice.
"Luck" is when preparation meets opportunity.
I prefer fishing evolution to fishing extinction.
If ya want to clean up the water, ya gotta get the pigs out of the creek.
CaptainOriginal Crew2,216 postsSince 2018
Leprechaun
LeprechaunMODnoreaster.com2025#1187
Fished yesterday on a VERY rough ocean with Capt. Mike and George. Some biggies rolled under my keel this trip, that's for sure. Anyway, no real shot at legit jigging, we went right to the B/S Rigs with 6oz sinkers. It was almost impossible to keep from hanging up, as the waves would carry us up and then coming down into the trough would drop our rigs right into the rubble. First time in 29 years owning this boat that I ran out of a specific size sinker. We had to have gone thru at least 20 of 'em, completely emptying the 6oz box.

That NW breeze really had it rolling out there, making me glad that we were in a keeled inboard, rather than a modern Deep-Vee. Now THAT would have been uncomfortable!

Anyway, ended with 4 keepers to 4+lbs for a ton of effort. I was still swaying in the shower, hours later.

IMG_7077.webp

Tonight wifey and I turned our share of the catch into a kind of oreganata/scampi broil, topped with coarse chopped shrimp, the zest of one lemon, garlic, parsley, a chopped half of a medium-sized red onion, one fine-diced Italian long pepper (NO seeds!), seasoned bread crumbs mixed with panko, a pinch of oregano, EVOO, lemon juice, topped with thin butter patties, paprika and a bit more chopped curly parsley. 8 minutes at 400-deg, then 2 mins under the broiler, and MAN did it go down easy! Really a winner entrée.

IMG_7083 (2).webp

Paired it with a good quality Vodka & Tonic - hey, this may be an off-year for the catching, but it's banner year for the cooking!

IMG_7083 (1).webp
"Luck" is when preparation meets opportunity.
I prefer fishing evolution to fishing extinction.
If ya want to clean up the water, ya gotta get the pigs out of the creek.
CaptainOriginal Crew2,216 postsSince 2018
captmike28
Fished yesterday on a VERY rough ocean with Capt. Mike and George. Some biggies rolled under my keel yesterday, that's for sure. Anyway, no real shot at legit jigging, we went right to the B/S Rigs with 6oz sinkers. It was almost impossible to keep from hanging up, as the waves would carry us up and then coming down into the trough would drop our rigs right into the rubble. First time in 29 years owning this boat that I ran out of a specific size sinker. We had to have gone thru at least 20 of 'em, completely emptying the 6oz box.

That NW breeze really had it rolling out there, making me glad that we were in a keeled inboard, rather than a modern Deep-Vee. Now THAT would have been uncomfortable!

Anyway, ended with 4 keepers to 4+lbs for a ton of effort. I was still swaying in the shower, hours later.

View attachment 104958

Tonite wifey and I turned our share of the catch into a kind of oreganata/scampi broil, topped with coarse chopped shrimp, the zest of one lemon, garlic, parsley, a chopped half red onion, one fine-diced Italian long pepper (NO seeds!), seasoned bread crumbs mixed with panko, EVOO, lemon juice. butter patties and topped with paprika and more chopped curly parsley. 8 minutes at 400-deg, then 2 mins under the broiler, and MAN did it go down easy! Really a winner entree.

View attachment 104959

Paired it with a good quality Vodka & Tonic - hey, this may be an off-year for catching, but it's banner year for the cooking!

View attachment 104960
We did the best we possibly could with the lousy sea conditions.
It may have been a "workout" but it was still fun fishing with a couple of good friends.
CaptainOriginal Crew1,853 postsSince 2018
longcast
Fished yesterday on a VERY rough ocean with Capt. Mike and George. Some biggies rolled under my keel yesterday, that's for sure. Anyway, no real shot at legit jigging, we went right to the B/S Rigs with 6oz sinkers. It was almost impossible to keep from hanging up, as the waves would carry us up and then coming down into the trough would drop our rigs right into the rubble. First time in 29 years owning this boat that I ran out of a specific size sinker. We had to have gone thru at least 20 of 'em, completely emptying the 6oz box.

That NW breeze really had it rolling out there, making me glad that we were in a keeled inboard, rather than a modern Deep-Vee. Now THAT would have been uncomfortable!

Anyway, ended with 4 keepers to 4+lbs for a ton of effort. I was still swaying in the shower, hours later.

View attachment 104958

Tonite wifey and I turned our share of the catch into a kind of oreganata/scampi broil, topped with coarse chopped shrimp, the zest of one lemon, garlic, parsley, a chopped half red onion, one fine-diced Italian long pepper (NO seeds!), seasoned bread crumbs mixed with panko, EVOO, lemon juice. butter patties and topped with paprika and more chopped curly parsley. 8 minutes at 400-deg, then 2 mins under the broiler, and MAN did it go down easy! Really a winner entree.

View attachment 104959

Paired it with a good quality Vodka & Tonic - hey, this may be an off-year for catching, but it's banner year for the cooking!

View attachment 104960
That dish looks (and I am sure tastes) delicious!! Will add that one to the cycle.
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
george
georgeADMINnoreaster.com2025#1190
IMG_2605.webp

I made up a fluke sashimi for lunch with fresh home grown jalepeno and cucumber.

As for the trip . . It was an expensive one. I've never seem so many rigs lost instantly in my life. After loosing a few $9, 6 ounce bucktails with teasers and gulp, I switched to losing Petes 6 ounce sinkers! Sorry Pete, but I never carry lead.

So we got our butts kicked, lost a lot of tackle and took home 4 fish. Doesn't seem like a great day, but when you have the right chemistry on a boat, it's always a good day.
George R. Scocca
george@nyangler.com
www.nyangler.com - Your Secret Spot Online !
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,174 postsSince 2018
Leprechaun
LeprechaunMODnoreaster.com2025#1191
Kevin - sauté the topping 3/4-cooked thru before assembling the fillet & topping for baking/broiling.
"Luck" is when preparation meets opportunity.
I prefer fishing evolution to fishing extinction.
If ya want to clean up the water, ya gotta get the pigs out of the creek.
CaptainOriginal Crew2,216 postsSince 2018
longcast
Kevin - sauté the topping 3/4-cooked thru before assembling the fillet/topping for baking/broiling.
The subtle touches..........................Thank you!
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
longcast
Fished the bay the last 2 days. 50+ fish with Saturday being the better day. 2 keeps at 21 and 23. One each day. Frustrating when 12 fish measured over 19 and less than 19.5 and super fat and thick. Great to be out. Little for the table. Peanuts the key. What a sight me throwing the net. lol.

IMG_9017.webp
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
longcast
Well, 18 bay fish today. Zero NY keepers, but, NJ would be most of them lol. Bunch between 19 1/4 but less than 19 1/2. Fished peanuts but most caught on 1/4 oz jig with Gulp green chrome jerk shads. It was a wet one today!
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
captmike28
Well, 18 bay fish today. Zero NY keepers, but, NJ would be most of them lol. Bunch between 19 1/4 but less than 19 1/2. Fished peanuts but most caught on 1/4 oz jig with Gulp green chrome jerk shads. It was a wet one today!
Wow, frustrating a hell but I admire your persistence, especially in the rain!!
CaptainOriginal Crew1,853 postsSince 2018
george
georgeADMINnoreaster.com2025#1196
Not to take this off subject, but this is a great read on what's really happening with fluke management and migration. The Great Fluke Migration
George R. Scocca
george@nyangler.com
www.nyangler.com - Your Secret Spot Online !
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,174 postsSince 2018
longcast
Started out real early to get fuel and find the peanuts. They eluded me real good for a bit but perseverance paid off. Interesting how many mullet came up in the net. Could that be a great surf run in the next week? Anyway, got to the areas a little later than intended but dropped the lines in. First spot - zero. Ugh. Is this my day? Moved around a bit and found them good. Many peanuts sacrificed their young lives to assist putting 14 keeps in the boat and 7 shorts. Mind you, the shorts were 19 -19 1/4. Just an awesome and savage bay bite. Peanuts on a 3/0 hook with a 1/2 oz egg sinker on a light spinning rod. Each fish was a powerhouse on the fight, ripping drag and running around the boat, embarrassing me with each swing of the net. When the carnage was done, ended with a 6 3/4 pounder, a 5 even pounder and 4 3/4 pounder in the ice. Pictures are scarce as my son cancelled on my late last night. Last year he was the man for weight and numbers. Anyway, sent him pictures along the way to rub it in, LOL.
Be safe, not cold or rough enough to clear the water of the problems. Soon!IMG_9091.webpIMG_9101.webp
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
captmike28
Started out real early to get fuel and find the peanuts. They eluded me real good for a bit but perseverance paid off. Interesting how many mullet came up in the net. Could that be a great surf run in the next week? Anyway, got to the areas a little later than intended but dropped the lines in. First spot - zero. Ugh. Is this my day? Moved around a bit and found them good. Many peanuts sacrificed their young lives to assist putting 14 keeps in the boat and 7 shorts. Mind you, the shorts were 19 -19 1/4. Just an awesome and savage bay bite. Peanuts on a 3/0 hook with a 1/2 oz egg sinker on a light spinning rod. Each fish was a powerhouse on the fight, ripping drag and running around the boat, embarrassing me with each swing of the net. When the carnage was done, ended with a 6 3/4 pounder, a 5 even pounder and 4 3/4 pounder in the ice. Pictures are scarce as my son cancelled on my late last night. Last year he was the man for weight and numbers. Anyway, sent him pictures along the way to rub it in, LOL.
Be safe, not cold or rough enough to clear the water of the problems. Soon!View attachment 105572View attachment 105573
Wow, fantastic trip, Kevin. I'm hearing that right now live peanuts are indeed magic.
CaptainOriginal Crew1,853 postsSince 2018
Chinacat
Started out real early to get fuel and find the peanuts. They eluded me real good for a bit but perseverance paid off. Interesting how many mullet came up in the net. Could that be a great surf run in the next week? Anyway, got to the areas a little later than intended but dropped the lines in. First spot - zero. Ugh. Is this my day? Moved around a bit and found them good. Many peanuts sacrificed their young lives to assist putting 14 keeps in the boat and 7 shorts. Mind you, the shorts were 19 -19 1/4. Just an awesome and savage bay bite. Peanuts on a 3/0 hook with a 1/2 oz egg sinker on a light spinning rod. Each fish was a powerhouse on the fight, ripping drag and running around the boat, embarrassing me with each swing of the net. When the carnage was done, ended with a 6 3/4 pounder, a 5 even pounder and 4 3/4 pounder in the ice. Pictures are scarce as my son cancelled on my late last night. Last year he was the man for weight and numbers. Anyway, sent him pictures along the way to rub it in, LOL.
Be safe, not cold or rough enough to clear the water of the problems. Soon!View attachment 105572View attachment 105573
Fantastic!
What a day
That’s awesome!
At least I'm enjoyin' the ride.....
CommodoreOriginal Crew7,065 postsSince 2018
Chinacat
Wow, fantastic trip, Kevin. I'm hearing that right now live peanuts are indeed magic.
Im hearing the same 😎
At least I'm enjoyin' the ride.....
CommodoreOriginal Crew7,065 postsSince 2018

Sign in to reply to this thread.

Thread
Post your 2019-2025 Fluke Pix & Trip Reports Here!
Sign in