Ok thanks, that 3.5% gain is better than other increases on some high rise units here along the Fort Lauderdale strip, surprising... a diversified stock fund will outperform this real estate thing,; contemplating buying or renting, ... cellie...
Then to do a proper P&L, you should contemplate your rental costs as a loss against investments if you choose not to buy...
Since you obviously like "God's Waiting Room" you should also factor in the state income tax savings, should you be able to endure staying down there for six months and 1 day a year.
I've run the numbers against IL, where no retirement-related income is taxed, so we could be closer to our children and grandchildren, but come up against a very strong, "I like all 4 seasons and would hate to stay away from Maine for over 6 months a year!! Furthermore the gross income tax savings wouldn't cover the expenses of another house or a condo, so screw that!!"