noreaster.com
Forum/Fishing Reports/Magnolia pier

Magnolia pier

InshoreNew YorkSurf
2,077 views·26 replies·by Bassmaster·First Post·Latest
Bassmaster
BassmasterFREE2025#1
My neighbor gave me a copy of the fisherman and I saw long beach magnolia pier. Its walking distance from the long Island rail road plenty of places to eat in the neighboorhpod also a rest area a feliet board if you get a keeper a tackle shop. Plenty of parking. Amazing setup. I started with the diamond jig I saw alot of peanut bunker and I missed a bluefish. That fishing stopped and I went to using worms and I caught 6 sea bass 2 sea Robins and a spot. Had a great time. I will be going back only if I can't go on a party Boat due to rough seas. Tight lines.
CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
MOJOE
MOJOEMODnoreaster.com2025#2
Bassmaster when it gets cold Jan//Feb that pier is real good for herring ,,,,,,,,><))))*>
><))))*>
EAT FISH LIVE LONGER >
AdmiralOriginal Crew25,823 postsSince 2018
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREE2025#3
My dad loved fishing that pier. Usually caught something too!
"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
Bassmaster
BassmasterFREE2025#4
Today i went fishing at magnolia pier and it was insane fishing 15 blues in 2 and a half hours using lures. Will have a video later.
CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREE2025#5
Awesome! 👍
"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
longcast
longcastFREE2025#6
Today i went fishing at magnolia pier and it was insane fishing 15 blues in 2 and a half hours using lures. Will have a video later.
It is that time of year. Great catch!
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
Bassmaster
BassmasterFREE2025#7
CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
Bassmaster
BassmasterFREE2025#8
CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
MOJOE
MOJOEMODnoreaster.com2025#9
Nice capt 😎 ,,,,,,,,,,,,><))))*>
><))))*>
EAT FISH LIVE LONGER >
AdmiralOriginal Crew25,823 postsSince 2018
wader
waderFREE2025#10
@Bassmaster understand good herring fishing there as well later in the Fall.........
"Well, it's alright.
.............even if you're old and gray."
"Well, it's alright.
............you still got something to say."
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,900 postsSince 2018
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREE2025#11
@Bassmaster understand good herring fishing there as well later in the Fall.........
There hasn't been a good herring run in a long time.
"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
Bassmaster
Will try herring this winter hopefully there are some around.
CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREE2025#13
They used to be so thick in that area you could snag a bucket while flounder fishing.
"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
Bassmaster
Yesterday I went fishing at magnolia pier and the fishing was awesome. What a day of fishing. Had 4 different species of fish. 3 spots 1 bluefish one blowfish and 30 or 40 small sea bass. I bought two poles one for the blues and one for the tiny fish. Going forward going for blues at magnolia until they are gone. Tight lines
CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
Bassmaster
CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
Bassmaster
Today I was fishing at magnolia pier and it was insane fishing. I was using a Sabitki rig. I had snappers sea bass shad peanut bunker and a fish I am not sure what it is. I will post a video and maybe you can help me. Had 30 snappers 30 sea bass 25 of the fish I am not sure of and 15 shad. Lots of fluke caught and a big keeper had to be 3 lbs. sorry no pic or video. Also an 18 inch fluke was caught. Sea robins When I got there a 4 Pound blue was landed on a live snapper. Going to go out on Saturday at magnolia. Tight lines.

CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
The3fishheads
Silver perch.
Deckhand22 postsSince 2021
Bassmaster
Silver perch.
Thank you
CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
Bassmaster
It says it’s a freshwater fish. I caught this at magnolia pier
CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
wader
waderFREE2025#20
It says it’s a freshwater fish. I caught this at magnolia pier
Perch can do brackish water. I used to get Yellow Perch at Whites Pool in Smithtown which feeds the Nissequogue.
"Well, it's alright.
.............even if you're old and gray."
"Well, it's alright.
............you still got something to say."
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,900 postsSince 2018

Sign in to reply to this thread.

Thread
Magnolia pier
Sign in