noreaster.com
Forum/General Discussion/Fishing in Gardiner NY

Fishing in Gardiner NY

28 views·6 replies·by BoatGuy
BoatGuy
BoatGuynoreaster.comSep 20#1

We are taking a multi-family trip to Gardiner NY. My wife mentioned there is a stream right behind the house we’re renting.

Questions:

I assume there must be (assuming fresh water) fish in the stream. Mostly I fish from the Long Island Sound. Any helpful freshwater hints appreciated.
am assuming I need to get a fresh water license?

First MateOriginal Crew780 postsSince 2019
DMamba
DMambaFREESep 21#2

Hey BoatGuy, I am no pro to freshwater fishing, but have been doing more of it in the last year just to satisfy my urge to fish when I can't get out into the Sound or Bay. Fishing license isn't bad, you can get one for the day, the week or the year so you can decide which works best for you.
Hard to know exactly what will be available to you in that creek, but I looked quickly at a map to determine those creeks in that are run out from Wallkill River, which reportedly has a lot of small mouth bass. Small mouth bass pick up on scents, so that could be an angle to take advantage of. I would probably grab a small scented soft plastic, some worms too, and maybe a rooster tail or something to have a few options. But, if you're only wishing to do this once, then I could understand not wanting to fill a tackle box with a bunch of stuff you won't use again lol. Idk how fast the creek moves but I would assume you'd be ok with some split shots for weight.

Deckhand3 postsSince 2026
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREESep 21#3

One thing I learned from the various ponds and creeks that I've wet a line in is the rooster tail lure works great for whatever is swimming around. I always used to pack an ultralight rod with a few roosters when traveling upstate or Pennsylvania.

"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
DMamba
DMambaFREESep 21#4

Being able to cover ground, the rooster tail is nice to find out where the fish may be at. The vibration it sends too is attractive to fish. If you get something as the all around, lets find out what's swimming in this water, that is a good place to start, I think.

Deckhand3 postsSince 2026
BoatGuy
BoatGuynoreaster.comSep 21#5

Can you buy the rooster tail lure locally near Rocky Point. Leaving soon so I can't mail order it.

First MateOriginal Crew780 postsSince 2019
BoatGuy
BoatGuynoreaster.comSep 21#6

I was also thinking of paddletails. What type of jig is good for the front?

First MateOriginal Crew780 postsSince 2019
longcast
longcastFREESep 21#7

Google the area and look for a tackle shop. I bet they have all the "right" colors etc., and spending money they may share some intel. I do it all the time.

Most recently that protocol put a shore bound tarpon up for me while the locals made fun of my car and clothes, lol.

AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019

Sign in to reply to this thread.

Thread
Fishing in Gardiner NY
Sign in