noreaster.com
Forum/General Discussion/Fluke Season 2026 Analysis

Fluke Season 2026 Analysis

11,535 views·110 replies·by hartattack·First Post·Latest
hawk375
hawk375FREEOct 7#21

We all would like to think just because we throw it back it will live but reality is a lot will die both rec and comm i would have to agree a dragger catch and release would kill more of the released fish my only problem is why do recs have to use most of there limit to catch and release mortality instead of smaller size where the fish would become food instead of bait

Mate118 postsSince 2020
MakoMatt
MakoMattMODnoreaster.comOct 7#22
hawk375
We all would like to think just because we throw it back it will live but reality is a lot will die both rec and comm i would have to agree a dragger catch and release would kill more of the released fish my only problem is why do recs have to use most of there limit to catch and release mortality instead of smaller size where the fish would become food instead of bait

I think the larger size limit has to due with the shear numbers of recreational fishermen, and the impact we would have to the fishery.

It is estimated that there are over 2 million saltwater anglers just between NY and NJ.

There didn’t seem to be any problem this year catching undersized fish. Let’s say as an example these 2 million plus anglers went Fluke fishing only 3 times a year, and caught one, one pound fish to bring home each trip.

That’s 6 million pounds of Fluke removed from the biomass. Based on my example, (which is just an example to illustrate the impact we have)
NOAA has allotted 8.79 million pounds for the entire east coast, we would have used more than 2/3 of the entire east coast allocation.

And discard mortality would certainly still be a problem.

CaptainOriginal Crew2,132 postsSince 2018
Snapprhead27

Do we think it's time to go to a slot for Fluke, similar to striped bass? The bigger fluke seem to be females. I remember years back going out of Captree and there was the RSA permit. Keeping fluke for a certain time frame at a different length.

Commodore5,031 postsSince 2020
Matts
MattsFREEOct 7#24

Let me throw some more experiences out there.
I so not believe that there is a substantial fluke dragging industry in the central Sound, but maybe there is.
I don't know how much fluke travel from year to year, but I suspect it's not much. or maybe I'm wrong
For 2-3 years we had a month of lock and load fluke fishing for 15-18" fluke under sand eels in Smithtown bay.
Those fish did not come back bigger each successive year.
And this year, the bite never materialized (or you guys did a great job of keeping your mouths shut).
Maybe all the fluke go offshore in the winter and some opt to head to the sound in the spring, so maybe none of this means anything or maybe it adds to the confounding data?
I've tried asking the fluke, but they refuse to answer.

First MateOriginal Crew693 postsSince 2019
longcast
longcastFREEOct 7#25
MakoMatt
I think the larger size limit has to due with the shear numbers of recreational fishermen, and the impact we would have to the fishery.

It is estimated that there are over 2 million saltwater anglers just between NY and NJ.

There didn’t seem to be any problem this year catching undersized fish. Let’s say as an example these 2 million plus anglers went Fluke fishing only 3 times a year, and caught one, one pound fish to bring home each trip.

That’s 6 million pounds of Fluke removed from the biomass. Based on my example, (which is just an example to illustrate the impact we have)
NOAA has allotted 8.79 million pounds for the entire east coast, we would have used more than 2/3 of the entire east coast allocation.

And discard mortality would certainly still be a problem.

That’s 6 million pounds of Fluke removed from the biomass. Based on my example, (which is just an example to illustrate the impact we have)
NOAA has allotted 8.79 million pounds for the entire east coast, we would have used more than 2/3 of the entire east coast allocation.

Sounds good to me................

AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
hawk375
hawk375FREEOct 8#26

anyone who thinks any of what noaa is saying should listen to weather forecast which is all more sophisticated than noaa's research on amount of fish and rec trips should wonder how accurate there numbers are and then look at success this system has resulted in and say made we need a change?

Mate118 postsSince 2020
MakoMatt
MakoMattMODnoreaster.comOct 8#27

I would have to think that if the size of keeper Fluke was lowered to 14” there would have to be an offset that would reduce both the season length, and the quantity per angler.

Keep in mind too that a 14” Fluke would yield approx. 1/2 pound of fillets……. and that’s if you are really good with the knife.

CaptainOriginal Crew2,132 postsSince 2018
longcast
longcastFREEOct 8#28
MakoMatt
I would have to think that if the size of keeper Fluke was lowered to 14” there would have to be an offset that would reduce both the season length, and the quantity per angler.

Keep in mind too that a 14” Fluke would yield approx. 1/2 pound of fillets……. and that’s if you are really good with the knife.

I hold my own. Had a very good local teacher.

attachment-120294

AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
longcast
longcastFREEOct 8#29
MakoMatt
I would have to think that if the size of keeper Fluke was lowered to 14” there would have to be an offset that would reduce both the season length, and the quantity per angler.

Keep in mind too that a 14” Fluke would yield approx. 1/2 pound of fillets……. and that’s if you are really good with the knife.

Food for my family and not a net.

AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREEOct 8#30
MakoMatt
I would have to think that if the size of keeper Fluke was lowered to 14” there would have to be an offset that would reduce both the season length, and the quantity per angler.

Keep in mind too that a 14” Fluke would yield approx. 1/2 pound of fillets……. and that’s if you are really good with the knife.

Comms. don't seem to mind.

"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
MakoMatt
MakoMattMODnoreaster.comOct 8#31
longcast
I hold my own. Had a very good local teacher.

attachment 120294

Some nice looking fillets you have there.

Fillets from a 14” fish would be less than 1/4 pound each side wouldn’t compare at all to those.

CaptainOriginal Crew2,132 postsSince 2018
MakoMatt
MakoMattMODnoreaster.comOct 8#32
OVERBORED
Comms. don't seem to mind.

I get the impression that you would just prefer no regulations, and we go back to the wild Wild West free-for-all.

I don’t fish for food, and I’m not alone. For me, the food aspect of fishing is a nice perk, but not why I do it.

CaptainOriginal Crew2,132 postsSince 2018
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREEOct 8#33

There you go Assuming again!

Keep the current regulations but close the winter fishery!

That's all I ask............

"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
MakoMatt
MakoMattMODnoreaster.comOct 8#34
OVERBORED
There you go Assuming again!

Keep the current regulations but close the winter fishery!

That's all I ask............

So you would prefer they drag the bottom inshore in the Spring, or Summer, or Fall?

CaptainOriginal Crew2,132 postsSince 2018
hartattack
hartattackFREEOct 8#35
MakoMatt
So you would prefer they drag the bottom inshore in the Spring, or Summer, or Fall?

The winter off shore spawn is when the comms target this naturally occurring fluke biomass, thus facilitating upgrading to larger fish for higher prices. Maybe the biggest offending comms (Virginia and North Carolina) would changer their ways if the winter spawn period is outlawed. All I know is NO COMM REG CHANGE has gotten us into this mess!

Once in a while you can get shown the light
In the strangest of places if you look at it right
First MateOriginal Crew286 postsSince 2018
MakoMatt
MakoMattMODnoreaster.comOct 8#36
hartattack
The winter off shore spawn is when the comms target this naturally occurring fluke biomass, thus facilitating upgrading to larger fish for higher prices. Maybe the biggest offending comms (Virginia and North Carolina) would changer their ways if the winter spawn period is outlawed. All I know is NO COMM REG CHANGE has gotten us into this mess!

“Maybe the biggest offending comms (Virginia and North Carolina) would changer their ways if the winter spawn period is outlawed.”

Why……. do you think they will abide by the regulations if they ban the offshore winter commercial fishery?

Maybe the regulations need to be changed, but I think the first and easiest thing to do would be to enforce the regulations. And how do you know Virginia and North Carolina breaking the law???

CaptainOriginal Crew2,132 postsSince 2018
hawk375
hawk375FREEOct 9#37

the sad part is we all catch and kill fish but to always blame the commercial is crazy maybe 16 size for both i dont know but to waste all these fish make no sense

Mate118 postsSince 2020
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREEOct 9#38
MakoMatt
So you would prefer they drag the bottom inshore in the Spring, or Summer, or Fall?

They already do!

"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREEOct 9#39
hawk375
the sad part is we all catch and kill fish but to always blame the commercial is crazy maybe 16 size for both i dont know but to waste all these fish make no sense

Let's start with the allocation of quota then the disparity between size limit which change on an annual basis for recs but not comms..

"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
MakoMatt
MakoMattMODnoreaster.comOct 9#40
OVERBORED
They already do!

Yes, they do, but to reach their quota only fishing the inshore waters is that some something you would prefer? No need to answer it’s rhetorical.

CaptainOriginal Crew2,132 postsSince 2018

Sign in to reply to this thread.

Thread
Fluke Season 2026 Analysis
Sign in