So you're against catch and release? And who says what they say is gospel. Because there's plenty of fish that have flexible seasons. George they really don't have numbers on mortality. And when asked to the director of the DEC how many striped bass are in the ocean well as said earlier, they don't know. George look across the board on here, social media and websites. Many without going into names my boats included boast of epic I think the word used most often epic striper fishing today. Over 80 plus fish, hmm makes you think. So in essence all involved commercial, sporties, charters are decimating the fishery that's what you said with no repercussions. Hey George in probably 5 years or so most commercial striper fishermen will be too old or dead that being the light at the end of the tunnel. Who will they blame then?
A little knowledge is dangerous. Why wait for gamefish status? I'm a charter boat owner/operator. Of the hundreds of times, I fish a year charter or with friends 99% are fishing for striped bass. I fished Connecticut several times last week, slots all released, they looked pretty good to me swimming away. On any given day there's plenty of fisherman along the river. Fishing and catching stripers I've never seen one kept. George I 've met you and consider you a gentleman but you're good at stoking the flames between the commercial and charter fisherman. That really doesn't accomplish much except make for banter between all. Rather than tear down I say build up. Here's my cell 516 7286952 I'm willing to host a forum . discuss options for all and see who is willing to fund these solutions. I've had several commercial fisherman who want to assist in putting "they" in check and be all inclusive once again to all the problems plaguing the stripers. Without going into attack made let all resolve to helping this great resource.
I'm not sure why you think I'm against catch and release (C&R); it's practically all we do now when fishing for bass. The ASMFC isn't a fan, arguing that it leads to the death of millions of pounds of fish annually. We both aim for the same outcome, but without advocates, we risk losing access to the fishery entirely. Had we not fought for our rights in the early '90s, we'd be limited to a much smaller share of the catch. Nowadays, recreational anglers account for 90% of the catch, and it's become nearly impossible to take a fish home.

You seem to underestimate the number of people who appreciate taking a fish home. The demand is there; otherwise, party boats targeting bass would lose their business.

Vinnie, you're in a special position with a clientele that prefers C&R. However, if the ASMFC closes a fishery, that's it—you can't fish there, leaving you with limited options during that season.

Just to be clear, I'm not trying to provoke anyone. I'm merely highlighting significant concerns that have been raised at high levels. We're not safe yet; the upcoming spring assessment will be critical, and a total shutdown wouldn't be surprising.