Well, (and this is a generality) the more carbon in a rod, the more "sensitive" its supposed to be. That's the popular industry trope anyway. Also in general, the more brittle - that's the part they don't like to talk about. A very high-carbon content blank is more prone to breaking - and must never be high-sticked.
Now as far as comparing the two Shimano rod lines you are interested in - The truth of the matter is that Shimano is the absolute master at telling you what they want you to hear, not necessarily what you really want to know. The best advertising department in the Industry, Shimano has.
There is no way to quantify what 70% vs 80% actually does for you without actually fishing the rods. That's why I asked for opinions from those that may have fished both rod families. This whole carbon fiber blank composition thing is very complicated, having a good bit more to do with how the carbon fiber cloth is laid on the rod mandrel, and less about the overall carbon content. Not to mention the TYPE of carbon fiber cloth used, which is another whole lengthy discussion I won't go into here.
This new-ish spiral wraping of the blank with a visible carbon tape started about 25 or more years ago in Asia (believe it or not Bass Pro Shops offered it on some of their Chinese-built rods over 25 yrs ago!), and was picked up here in the states by the original United Composites rod company - they called it "Double Helix" I believe. Not new and not their proprietary technology - despite some thinking that's the case. The whole idea of such a blank building method is to increase "hoop strength" so to prevent the rod blank from "oval-ing" under extreme bend. This is one of the main causes of blank failure under load and what many rod companies have been working on eliminating over the past 40 or so years.
If you want my WAG (wild-ass guess), here's what I think on the increased carbon content in the Game Type-G series. I think its because Shimano uses no fiber glass scrim as their first layer against the rod mandrel. Explanation follows - and this is getting into how the sausage gets made in the rod blank manufacturing world, so hang in there:
Because graphite (carbon) rods have always been more delicate than glass or glass/composite rods, most manufacturers put a super-thin first layer made of very fine fiberglass against the rod mandrel, prior to wrapping on the graphite cloth. This has always been the case, but it does take a bit away from the overall sensitivity of the finished blank.
Some firms, such as CTS in New Zealand and Hydra and Edge/NFC here in the USA (Edge/NFC is Gary Loomis' new company after his non-compete agreement with Shimano ran out, post Shimano's acquisition of the original G. Loomis company), all found a way of using NO fiberglass scrip in their blanks.
I don't believe they all do it exactly the same way, there are international patents involved I'm sure. But they all do it, for certain. This does increase sensitivity while not greatly increasing breakage, viz-a-viz more traditionally built graphite rods. But they still will break if you push them past their engineered limits (Edge and CTS have had their issues with breakage in the past before ironing out the issues. Mostly.)
So, here's my WAG: I think that Shimano is using some type of "fiber glass scrim-less" technology in their Game Type-J's, which they do not use in their Grappler rods. That's my thinking as to why they boast of a higher carbon content by 10% in the Game Type J rods. Again, just a guess on my part.
Bottom line, is this better and worth $100+ more of cost? I can't say, never having fished a Game Type-J rod. I can say that without a doubt the little Grappler Type-J that I own (the 6' ML spinning version) slugged it out with a 6' Brown shark in 80' of water two Summers ago, and got him almost to the boat, before my 40lb rig wore through 10' from my boat.
That and the overall performance envelope, (including sensitivity and taper) of the Grappler Type-J series have made them my top choice, dollar for dollar, in the jigging market - and that's why you always see me recommending them, when asked about a mid-priced jigging stick. Are the Game Type-J's better? Maybe, but are they over $100 better? Again, maybe . . .
Shimano Grappler series rods..
"Luck" is when preparation meets opportunity.
I prefer fishing evolution to fishing extinction.
If ya want to clean up the water, ya gotta get the pigs out of the creek.
I prefer fishing evolution to fishing extinction.
If ya want to clean up the water, ya gotta get the pigs out of the creek.
CaptainOriginal Crew2,216 postsSince 2018
Sign in to reply to this thread.
Thread
Shimano Grappler series rods..