noreaster.com
Forum/Fishing Reports/Captain's Table - Montauk this week

Captain's Table - Montauk this week

11 views·48 replies·by captmike28·First Post·Latest
captmike28
captmike28FREEAug 13#1

This weeks stretch of good weather allowed me to run a couple of trips to Montauk searching for the elusive keeper Fluke.

Monday found Bruce, Steve, and young Brady join me for the first outing. Started at one of my favorite south side drops and on the second drift Bruce lands a nice 20” keeper to start us off. Steve managed to find a nice 18” keeper Sea Bass and then Bruce puts another similar Sea Bass in the box. Many more shorts of both species followed over the next hour before the tide and drift slowed up along with the bite.

So, we moved a bit further north and as the tide picked up so did the bite. First Bruce boxes another 20” Fluke then Steve’s rod doubles over and after a short but spirited battle he lands a nice 25” plus Fluke pushing the scales to almost 5.5#. As the balance of the day progressed, we had a steady pick of Fluke and Sea Bass with the occasional keeper finding the box during that time frame. Brady managed to catch the largest Fluke of the day, one just a bit larger than his dad’s fish. Plus, we found a good quantity of keeper Sea Bass in the mix as well. Final tally for the day was 6 keeper Fluke and 7 keeper Sea Bass, contributing to healthy bags of filet for their efforts.

Wednesday’s trip had my super experienced crew of Chef Nader, long time regular Matt, and other regular Bill join in for another stellar weather day on the ocean. So, based upon Monday’s results, I stopped at the more northern drop first and within a few drifts Bill puts the first 19.5” keeper Fluke in the box. A bunch more short Fluke and Sea Bass follow for the next hour until the tide dies as did the bite.

So, we mover further south and with a little boost from the tide the action resumes and we did manage to cull 3 more keeper Fluke to 21” from a ton of shorts. Lots of small Sea Bass as well but no keepers to this point on this trip which was kind of disappointing. Then the bite dies here so we head back north again and Bill lands another keeper Fluke of 21” pretty quickly so we are all encouraged. However, the balance of the day turned into a continuous stream of short Fluke and some small Sea Bass with just one keeper biscuit pulled by the Chef close to the end of the afternoon. Final tally yesterday only 5 keeper Fluke and 1 Sea Bass in the box. Just another testimonial to how difficult the Fluke fishing has been this year. Despite landing well over 75 Fluke the keeper ratio was really small. Friends I spoke with also out in the vicinity yesterday had even more meager results.

So, it looks like one of those “grind it out” types of years for our summer Fluke fishery. I have my “A Team” lined up for next Wednesday and we all hope the waters off Montauk will be willing to part with a lot more sizeable Fluke and Sea Bass. One thing is for sure; you can’t catch them from your couch, so we will persist in trying!

attachment-118698
attachment-118699

CaptainOriginal Crew1,853 postsSince 2018
Chinacat
ChinacatFREEAug 13#2

Thats as good as it gets!
Great job putting everyone on the fish
Love that picture of the young fellow holding a fish with the bent rod in the background 👍👍

At least I'm enjoyin' the ride.....
CommodoreOriginal Crew7,065 postsSince 2018
hawk375
hawk375FREEAug 14#3

wher are all the sea bass that were released last year?

Mate118 postsSince 2020
longcast
longcastFREEAug 14#4
hawk375
wher are all the sea bass that were released last year?

In pots and pin hookers baskets.

AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
hawk375
hawk375FREEAug 15#5

not caught and release mortality believe what you want keep drinking kool aid of ASMFC conservation equivalency it has worked wonders

Mate118 postsSince 2020
longcast
longcastFREEAug 15#6

Keep potting. Keep netting. Keep killing bycatch. Keep killing all. Just looking for a fresh fish dinner for the family.

AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
hawk375
hawk375FREEAug 16#7

like i said drink more kool aid

Mate118 postsSince 2020
Kona
KonaFREEAug 16#8

There are probably 25 “ lobster” pots on the Shinnecock reef now , up from a handful last year. I’ve spoken with DEC enforcement and they said “ lobster” gear is legal there, sea bass pot well so there seems to be a correlation between the amount of gear and lack of fish. Sucks.

First MateOriginal Crew271 postsSince 2019
Chinacat
ChinacatFREEAug 16#9
Kona
There are probably 25 “ lobster” pots on the Shinnecock reef now , up from a handful last year. I’ve spoken with DEC enforcement and they said “ lobster” gear is legal there, sea bass pot well so there seems to be a correlation between the amount of gear and lack of fish. Sucks.

I totally agree and was wondering myself how they get away with that
There are so many you have to pay close attention when fishing solo so you dont accidentally drift in to any

At least I'm enjoyin' the ride.....
CommodoreOriginal Crew7,065 postsSince 2018
longcast
longcastFREEAug 16#10
hawk375
not caught and release mortality believe what you want keep drinking kool aid of ASMFC conservation equivalency it has worked wonders

Catch and release mortality? Keep typing. Nonsense.

AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
hawk375
hawk375FREEAug 17#11

yeah the only nonsense is catch and release sea bass with blown up bladders thank god this kool aid won't kill you are you wouldn't be here

Mate118 postsSince 2020
longcast
longcastFREEAug 17#12
hawk375
yeah the only nonsense is catch and release sea bass with blown up bladders thank god this kool aid won't kill you are you wouldn't be here

All the sea bass I catch go back in great shape and swim right back to the bottom. Nets and pots kill. I do not.

AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
hawk375
hawk375FREEAug 17#13

whatever you think the numbers all say different maybe you are expert not everyone else is you seem to be very jealous of commercial fishing i am not of recreational i think all fishermen need fish and sorry to say we shouldn't waste fish because of regulations that are inconsistent from state to state keep blaming commercial fisherman and drink your kool aid

Mate118 postsSince 2020
longcast
longcastFREEAug 17#14
hawk375
whatever you think the numbers all say different maybe you are expert not everyone else is you seem to be very jealous of commercial fishing i am not of recreational i think all fishermen need fish and sorry to say we shouldn't waste fish because of regulations that are inconsistent from state to state keep blaming commercial fisherman and drink your kool aid

attachment-118851

AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
longcast
longcastFREEAug 17#15
hawk375
whatever you think the numbers all say different maybe you are expert not everyone else is you seem to be very jealous of commercial fishing i am not of recreational i think all fishermen need fish and sorry to say we shouldn't waste fish because of regulations that are inconsistent from state to state keep blaming commercial fisherman and drink your kool aid

If the netting and potting stops, would fish populations increase?

AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
longcast
longcastFREEAug 17#16
hawk375
whatever you think the numbers all say different maybe you are expert not everyone else is you seem to be very jealous of commercial fishing i am not of recreational i think all fishermen need fish and sorry to say we shouldn't waste fish because of regulations that are inconsistent from state to state keep blaming commercial fisherman and drink your kool aid

Jealousy? Of what?

Tell you what. How about we level the playing field. Can I keep an 11 inch seabass as a rec?

AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
Bassmaster
BassmasterFREEAug 17#17

This year I have probably caught over 500 fluke. One keeper so far. I like using my 4 ounce hammered gold jig. One trip i probably caught 70 fluke on this jig. Nothing worth measuring at all. I have used gulp but the last few trips I have used over 20 packages of gulp. The short fluke blowfish sea bass sea robins and other small species keep taking the tail. So I use sabitiki to catch bait and use that for fluke. And the diamond jigs. At least with the the diamond jig I can get other fish like Bonita sea bass blues and other species for dinner.

CaptainOriginal Crew4,960 postsSince 2019
hawk375
hawk375FREEAug 17#18

sorry jersey 12.5 ny 16 you fish same waters

Mate118 postsSince 2020
longcast
longcastFREEAug 17#19
hawk375
sorry jersey 12.5 ny 16 you fish same waters

So nobody at all can catch and keep an 11 inch seabass in NY?

AdmiralOriginal Crew20,417 postsSince 2019
hawk375
hawk375FREEAug 18#20

so you are jealous of com size limit ? or the ASMFC conservation equivalency which has lead to 61% of recreational landings being catch and release mortality there numbers not mine i only wonder what it is in NY with 16 inch size limit commercial fisherman and rec fisherman should come together to try to improve fishing so both industries will prosper not fight so govt gets in middle does a horrible job and two sides fight and let them get away with horrible job they have done for 40 years

Mate118 postsSince 2020

Sign in to reply to this thread.

Thread
Captain's Table - Montauk this week
Sign in