noreaster.com
Forum/Fisheries Management/Fluke. Seabass, Porgy Regs 2024

Fluke. Seabass, Porgy Regs 2024

7,014 views·63 replies·by hartattack·First Post·Latest
hartattack
hartattackFREE2024#1
Proposed changes are: fluke- 28% reduction, scup- 10% reduction, and Black Sea bass- no change.. see attached... this is for NY, NJ, CT. and all MAFMC waters..
Once in a while you can get shown the light
In the strangest of places if you look at it right
First MateOriginal Crew286 postsSince 2018
BoatGuy
BoatGuynoreaster.com2024#2
Not sure what this means: These measures are only intended to be used for states/regions which do not comply with the conservation equivalency process.

I assume this means that it is a suggestion and if NY does not come up with something “equivalent” we have to go with their regulation??
First MateOriginal Crew780 postsSince 2019
Roccus7
Roccus7MODnoreaster.com2024#3
Not sure what this means: These measures are only intended to be used for states/regions which do not comply with the conservation equivalency process.

I assume this means that it is a suggestion and if NY does not come up with something “equivalent” we have to go with their regulation??
Yeah, kinda sorta. It's complicated, but it should be no surprise that scup should be seeing a huge reduction in bag limits. The party boats have been pounding the crap out of them for the past 4 or so years to make up poor fishing/restrictive limits on fluke and BSB. At the behest of the For Hire fleets, the regulators have been kicking that can down the road for years and now it's payback time.

It's unfortunate, but the long-standing Party Boat business model of "C'mon board to fill the freezer" is now running up against severely diminished fish stocks. We're quickly approaching a "Come to Jesus" realization...
Shall I go to heaven or a-fishing? - H. D. Thoreau
Veni. Vidi. Cepi. - with apologies to Gaius Julius Caesar
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,717 postsSince 2018
BoatGuy
BoatGuynoreaster.com2024#4
Are they saying the new reulations for fluke will be...
"Precautionary default measures include a 20-inch minimum size, 2 fish possession limit, and open season from July 1-August 31."

I fish the Port Jeff area (Long Island Sound). I noticed some time ago that May and June I caught my bigger fish. As Crazy Alberto explained to me, the squid move through. By July all the big fish have moved out and continue to follow the squid. I am sure opening the season in July is not by mistake. I rather they just close the season. This stinks.
First MateOriginal Crew780 postsSince 2019
Double Trouble
Yeah, kinda sorta. It's complicated, but it should be no surprise that scup should be seeing a huge reduction in bag limits. The party boats have been pounding the crap out of them for the past 4 or so years to make up poor fishing/restrictive limits on fluke and BSB. At the behest of the For Hire fleets, the regulators have been kicking that can down the road for years and now it's payback time.

It's unfortunate, but the long-standing Party Boat business model of "C'mon board to fill the freezer" is now running up against severely diminished fish stocks. We're quickly approaching a "Come to Jesus" realization...
As usual they wait until the fishery is is in such bad shape and then blame the fishermen for the problem, instead of putting bag limits in place while the population is still healthy so the limits would not have to be so restrictive that it dont pay to go out.
Old to soon Smart to late
You can put lipstik on a pig but in the end its still a pig
My body thinks its 25 my mind thinks my body is an idiot
First MateOriginal Crew346 postsSince 2019
Roccus7
Roccus7MODnoreaster.com2024#6
As usual they wait until the fishery is is in such bad shape and then blame the fishermen for the problem, instead of putting bag limits in place while the population is still healthy so the limits would not have to be so restrictive that it dont pay to go out.
Couldn't agree more, but the other part of "as usual" is the second the regulators start talking about restrictive limits all aspects of the industry start screaming bloody murder that they're being put out of business.

One of my old bosses used to say, "If it's a big problem and you don't do something about it right away, it ends up disappearing"
Shall I go to heaven or a-fishing? - H. D. Thoreau
Veni. Vidi. Cepi. - with apologies to Gaius Julius Caesar
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,717 postsSince 2018
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREE2024#7
S
Yeah, kinda sorta. It's complicated, but it should be no surprise that scup should be seeing a huge reduction in bag limits. The party boats have been pounding the crap out of them for the past 4 or so years to make up poor fishing/restrictive limits on fluke and BSB. At the behest of the For Hire fleets, the regulators have been kicking that can down the road for years and now it's payback time.

It's unfortunate, but the long-standing Party Boat business model of "C'mon board to fill the freezer" is now running up against severely diminished fish stocks. We're quickly approaching a "Come to Jesus" realization...
Scup and Sea Bass fishing have never been better........ can't understand the reduction on scup..........
"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
Roccus7
Roccus7MODnoreaster.com2024#8
S
Scup and Sea Bass fishing have never been better........ can't understand the reduction on scup..........
The extremely generous bag limits over the past 4 or so years are putting the hurt on the population. Because of severe bag limits and tough fishing for fluke , BSB, stripers and tog, they've become the "Go To" fish for people intent on filling the freezer,

Yeah, there's lots of them, but keep it up and their won't be. @Double Trouble put it very succinctly, keep doing that, and they're won't be any.
Shall I go to heaven or a-fishing? - H. D. Thoreau
Veni. Vidi. Cepi. - with apologies to Gaius Julius Caesar
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,717 postsSince 2018
hawk375
hawk375FREE2024#9
the regulators are clueless if striped bass was an emergency what are flounder weakfish bluefish if you catch fish because they become available you get areduction this is what happens when the regulators sit at a desk and are arrogant enough to think they know how many fish are in the ocean
Mate118 postsSince 2020
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREE2024#10
Computer models can predict a lot of things............biomass isn't one of them!

Right now the Sea Bass are stacked up on wrecks from 180ft and deeper. Scup are anywhere from 40-90 fathom.

Problem is, you will never see a research vessel sampling in January when the fish congregate on the shelf and are easiest to assess.............
"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
george
georgeADMINnoreaster.com2024#11
S
Scup and Sea Bass fishing have never been better........ can't understand the reduction on scup..........
I agree. There are plenty of scup and sea bass. No reason for a reduction.
George R. Scocca
george@nyangler.com
www.nyangler.com - Your Secret Spot Online !
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,174 postsSince 2018
BoatGuy
BoatGuynoreaster.com2024#12
I wonder how the boats like Celtic Quest that make a living with Scup feel about this?
First MateOriginal Crew780 postsSince 2019
OVERBORED
OVERBOREDFREE2024#13
If it wasn't for scup, MANY boats would be out of business. That said, most could probably live with 15-20 fish........
"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
Roccus7
Roccus7MODnoreaster.com2024#14
...most could probably live with 15-20 fish........
That's the key comment. Can't treat any resource, no matter how plentiful it seems, to be infinite or you're doomed to failure.
Shall I go to heaven or a-fishing? - H. D. Thoreau
Veni. Vidi. Cepi. - with apologies to Gaius Julius Caesar
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,717 postsSince 2018
george
georgeADMINnoreaster.com2024#15
If it wasn't for scup, MANY boats would be out of business. That said, most could probably live with 15-20 fish........
They certainly have made it through worse. But the only people that I know who fish for scup are looking to put food in the fridge. 15- scup for $75 could hurt.
George R. Scocca
george@nyangler.com
www.nyangler.com - Your Secret Spot Online !
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,174 postsSince 2018
Roccus7
Roccus7MODnoreaster.com2024#16
They certainly have made it through worse. But the only people that I know who fish for scup are looking to put food in the fridge. 15- scup for $75 could hurt.
True, but $75 for a skunking hurts a lot worse.

I've learned to never calculate how much my "caught" fish dinners actually cost. It's a number I don't want to see, but when looked at as how much does it cost enjoy being on the water, it seems to be quite a bargain...
Shall I go to heaven or a-fishing? - H. D. Thoreau
Veni. Vidi. Cepi. - with apologies to Gaius Julius Caesar
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,717 postsSince 2018
george
georgeADMINnoreaster.com2024#17
True, but $75 for a skunking hurts a lot worse.

I've learned to never calculate how much my "caught" fish dinners actually cost. It's a number I don't want to see, but when looked at as how much does it cost enjoy being on the water, it seems to be quite a bargain...
I agree withyou there. But scup is a subsistence fishery for most.

I just did a $400 a man grouper trip for two fish! It's too simple not to calculate 🙂

$100 per fillet
$200 a fish.
George R. Scocca
george@nyangler.com
www.nyangler.com - Your Secret Spot Online !
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,174 postsSince 2018
Double Trouble
They certainly have made it through worse. But the only people that I know who fish for scup are looking to put food in the fridge. 15- scup for $75 could hurt.
Well then we could wait until they cant be found like they did with winter flounder.
Old to soon Smart to late
You can put lipstik on a pig but in the end its still a pig
My body thinks its 25 my mind thinks my body is an idiot
First MateOriginal Crew346 postsSince 2019
george
georgeADMINnoreaster.com2024#19
Well then we could wait until they cant be found like they did with winter flounder.
No comparison my friend. Also, keep in mind that winter flounder are flourishing. Just not in our polluted bays. They've moved offshore now and commercials are catching their full quotas.

Please don't get me wrong, I'm a fish first guy. Always have been and always will be. But Im also an advocate for recreational fishing.

The best thing for was scup would be no one fishing them at all. I realize that the govt tries to get it right, but sadly they're stuck at their desk looking at numbers that in most cases are correct about 50% of the time.

I'm doing this for over 35 years now and I can say that the micro managing of this, and other fisheries, with constant regulation changes, is obviously not the answer. It has never worked and never will.
George R. Scocca
george@nyangler.com
www.nyangler.com - Your Secret Spot Online !
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,174 postsSince 2018
captmike28
True, but $75 for a skunking hurts a lot worse.

I've learned to never calculate how much my "caught" fish dinners actually cost. It's a number I don't want to see, but when looked at as how much does it cost enjoy being on the water, it seems to be quite a bargain...
As is often the case I have mixed feelings about this issue. I agree completely with Roccus that recreational fishing should never be judged by the amount of fish one comes home with at the end of the day. I'm quite sure many of us learned long ago from whomever introduced us to this wonderful sport that it is the total experience that really matters.

On the other side of the coin, I have to look at things from my customers perspective as well. I do run a fair number of Scup Charters every year for groups of various interests and economic strata. For the most part, families with young kids and real hard-core light tackle enthusiasts love battling the large Spawners we are blessed with in the Peconics each spring and they are fine going home with just a handful of fish per person for their efforts.

But I also have a few groups that are really scraping together every dollar and count on making a big catch to offset some their own costs to feed themselves and their families. In fact, I often give these guys a break on the fare just to make things bit easier on them. Given the size of most Scup, even our spring Jumbos, it takes a lot to make a decent meal. A severe reduction in bag limit would definitely be a hardship on those folks.

I'm also puzzled about George's comment about a possible 15 fish bag limit. The proposed changes are calling for a 10% reduction, but 15 is half the current limit. I know it will be calculated by some "fudge factor" of total pounds of estimated harvest but that still seems like too steep a cut. Plus, I read they are also considering reopening the Federal waters for recreational harvest but at a 40 fish bag limit. What am I missing?
CaptainOriginal Crew1,853 postsSince 2018

Sign in to reply to this thread.

Thread
Fluke. Seabass, Porgy Regs 2024
Sign in