noreaster.com
Forum/General Discussion/Do they think we're idiots!

Do they think we're idiots!

58,996 views·738 replies·by george·First Post·Latest
Roccus7
Roccus7MODnoreaster.com2023#321
Right outside of Bath where they build Zumwalt and Arleigh Burke destroyers ? Asshats.
No, further out in 60 fathoms. Sub alleys.
Shall I go to heaven or a-fishing? - H. D. Thoreau
Veni. Vidi. Cepi. - with apologies to Gaius Julius Caesar
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,717 postsSince 2018
george
georgeADMINnoreaster.com2023#322
The recent deaths of seven whales off of the east coast, mostly humpbacks, got a lot of attention. The federal NOAA Fisheries Agency is responsible for whales. An outrageous statement by their spokesperson got me to do some research on humpback whale deaths.

The results are appalling. The evidence seems clear that offshore wind development is killing whales by the hundreds.

Here is the statement as reported in the press:

“NOAA said it has been studying what it calls “unusual mortality events” involving 174 humpback whales along the East Coast since January 2016. Agency spokesperson Lauren Gaches said that period pre-dates offshore wind preparation activities in the region.” Gaches is NOAA Fisheries press chief.

The “unusual mortality” data is astounding. Basically the humpback death rate roughly tripled starting in 2016 and continued high thereafter. You can see it here:

2016–2023 Humpback Whale Unusual Mortality Event Along the Atlantic Coast

But the claim that this huge jump in mortality predates offshore wind preparation activities is wildly false. In fact it coincides with the large scale onset of these activities. This strong correlation is strong evidence of causation, especially since no other possible cause has appeared.

To begin with, offshore lease sales really geared up 2015-16, with nine big sales off New Jersey, New York, Delaware and Massachusetts. These sales must have generated a lot of activity, likely including potentially damaging sonar.

In fact 2016 also saw the beginning of what are called geotechnical and site characterization surveys. These surveys are actually licensed by NOAA Fisheries, under what are called Incidental Harassment Authorizations or IHA’s.

There is some seriously misleading jargon here. IHA’s are incidental to some other activity, in this case offshore wind development. They are not incidental to the whales. In fact the term “harassment” specifically includes injuring the whales. That is called “level A harassment”.

To date NOAA has issued an astounding 46 one-year IHA’s for offshore wind sites. Site characterization typically includes the protracted use of what I call “machine gun sonar”. This shipboard device emits an incredibly loud noise several times a second, often for hours at a time, as the ship slowly maps the sea floor.

Mapping often takes many days to complete. A blaster can log hundreds of miles surveying a 10-by-10 mile site. Each IHA is typically for an entire year.

Here is a list of the IHA’s issued to date and those applied for:

Incidental Take Authorizations for Other Energy Activities (Renewable/LNG)

There are lots of ways this sonar blasting might cause whales to die. Simply fleeing the incredible noise could cause ship strikes or fish gear entanglements, the two leading causes of whale deaths. Of the whales could be deafened, increasing their chances of being struck by a ship later on. Direct bleeding injury, like getting their ears damaged, is another known risk, possibly leading to death from infection. So there can be a big time difference between blasting and death.

Note also that these deaths need not be in the immediate vicinity of the sonar blasting, so spatial correlation is unlikely. Humpbacks in particular are prodigious travelers. One group was tracked traveling 3,000 miles in just 28 days, over 100 miles a day on average. Another group routinely migrates 5,000 miles. Both are winter-summer migrations which can happen twice a year.

Thus a sonar blasting, site characterization in one place could easily lead to multiple whale deaths hundreds of miles away. If one of these blasters suddenly goes off near a group of whales they might go off in different directions, then slowly die.

The point is that the huge 2016 jump in annual humpback mortality coincides with the huge jump in NOAA Incidental Harassment Authorizations. It is that simple and surely NOAA Fisheries knows this.

Nor is this just about humpbacks. Some of the dead whales off New Jersey are endangered sperm whales. And of course there are the severely endangered North Atlantic Right Whales, on the verge of extinction.

Even worse, the IHA’s are about to make a much bigger jump. There are eleven pending IHA applications and eight of these are for actually constructing 8 different monster wind “farms”.

Driving the hundreds of enormous monopiles that hold up the turbine towers and blades will be far louder than the sonic blasters approved to date, especially with eight sites going at once. These construction sites range from Virginia to Massachusetts, with a concentration off New Jersey and New York.

For more on this noise see my https://www.cfact.org/2022/07/26/threat-to-endangered-whales-gets-louder/

Clearly we need a moratorium on new Incidental Harassment Authorizations until the safety of the whales and other marine species can be assured. Hundreds of whales may have already been killed by offshore wind activities. The evidence is right there.

Author​

George R. Scocca
george@nyangler.com
www.nyangler.com - Your Secret Spot Online !
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,174 postsSince 2018
OVERBORED
Everyone is getting sucked in
"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
WhatKnot
WhatKnotFREE2023#324
Talk about a coverup, this makes WaterGate look like a Sunday picnic. 😡
Be Safe
CommodoreOriginal Crew12,915 postsSince 2019
Matts
MattsFREE2023#325
I love whales as much as the next guy. I also love my fish finder, snow in the winter and the current shoreline configurations. This article, while sounding scientific, is nothing more than one man's guesswork. I don't see that it adds much to the conversation.

The author, who I am quite sure is not a marine biologist or whale anatomy expert, has not introduced any evidence other than coincidence. However, it seems that local whale and dolphin deaths have recently gone down from what they were just a few months ago, so what does that mean?

His assertions are also peppered with weasel words like "likely" and "potentially": "These sales must have generated a lot of activity, likely including potentially damaging sonar"
This is another way of saying that he has no idea when the sonic mapping started or whether the sonar is actually damaging or merely annoying to the whales.

"There are lots of ways this sonar blasting might cause whales to die." Or might not. Again, he has no idea.

"Simply fleeing the incredible noise could cause ship strikes or fish gear entanglements, the two leading causes of whale deaths."
The Nature article posted above suggests that the excessive noise does cause the whales to leave an area. But so what? Whales have tales. If the noise bothers them, I would expect them to leave. Later on, the author discusses how migratory these whales are. They are always moving. How this proves ship strikes and entanglements is beyond me.

"Or the whales could be deafened, increasing their chances of being struck by a ship later on." Or maybe they are not deafened. Pure speculation.

"Direct bleeding injury, like getting their ears damaged, is another known risk, possibly leading to death from infection. " Again, no proof of causation, just guessing. Have any of the dead whales been found to have burst eardrums?

My guess is loss of cold water krill and increased bunker inshore has led the whales closer to shore and closer to shipping and fishing areas - hence, the huge increase in whale watching Youtubes and TicToks
First MateOriginal Crew693 postsSince 2019
george
georgeADMINnoreaster.com2023#326
I love whales as much as the next guy. I also love my fish finder, snow in the winter and the current shoreline configurations. This article, while sounding scientific, is nothing more than one man's guesswork. I don't see that it adds much to the conversation.

The author, who I am quite sure is not a marine biologist or whale anatomy expert, has not introduced any evidence other than coincidence. However, it seems that local whale and dolphin deaths have recently gone down from what they were just a few months ago, so what does that mean?

His assertions are also peppered with weasel words like "likely" and "potentially": "These sales must have generated a lot of activity, likely including potentially damaging sonar"
This is another way of saying that he has no idea when the sonic mapping started or whether the sonar is actually damaging or merely annoying to the whales.

"There are lots of ways this sonar blasting might cause whales to die." Or might not. Again, he has no idea.

"Simply fleeing the incredible noise could cause ship strikes or fish gear entanglements, the two leading causes of whale deaths."
The Nature article posted above suggests that the excessive noise does cause the whales to leave an area. But so what? Whales have tales. If the noise bothers them, I would expect them to leave. Later on, the author discusses how migratory these whales are. They are always moving. How this proves ship strikes and entanglements is beyond me.

"Or the whales could be deafened, increasing their chances of being struck by a ship later on." Or maybe they are not deafened. Pure speculation.

"Direct bleeding injury, like getting their ears damaged, is another known risk, possibly leading to death from infection. " Again, no proof of causation, just guessing. Have any of the dead whales been found to have burst eardrums?

My guess is loss of cold water krill and increased bunker inshore has led the whales closer to shore and closer to shipping and fishing areas - hence, the huge increase in whale watching Youtubes and TicToks
I appreciate your opinion, but once again, I'll bring up the point that the wind industry has been permitted to kill the following:

Why would they issue these permits allowing the killing of what is listed above? I read that article before posting it, and your observations are correct. But at what point does the obvious no longer become a coincidence? Does common sense ever enter the conversation?

The North Atlantic right whale is one of the most endangered large whale species in the world, with only around 300 individuals remaining. They are listed as endangered under the Endangered Species Act and the Marine Mammal Protection Act and are protected from harm, harassment, and killing.

Under the Endangered Species Act (ESA), it is illegal to harm, harass, or kill any endangered or threatened species without a permit. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) issues permits for incidental take, which is the unintentional harming or killing of a protected species that occurs during otherwise lawful activities, such as commercial fishing or construction. The permit is only issued if the activity's benefits outweigh the potential harm to the species.

We can't even walk a beach with piping plovers on it, yet they're building a cement pole city directly in the path of an endangered species.

I guess someone decided that the benefits of wind energy outweigh the killing of these majestic creatures.
George R. Scocca
george@nyangler.com
www.nyangler.com - Your Secret Spot Online !
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,174 postsSince 2018
OVERBORED
And to think, the Japanese get vilified for sustainably harvesting whales which have been a part of their culture for centuries

Where are those sea shepherd AH when you need them!
"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
george
georgeADMINnoreaster.com2023#328
ATLANTIC CITY, N.J. (AP) — A joint study by two federal government scientific agencies and the commercial fishing industry documents numerous impacts that offshore wind power projects have on fish and marine mammals, including noise, vibration, electromagnetic fields and heat transfer that could alter the marine environment.
It comes as the offshore wind industry is poised to grow rapidly on the U.S. East Coast, where it is facing growing opposition from those who blame it for killing whales — something numerous scientific agencies say is not true.
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management and the Responsible Offshore Development Alliance issued their report Wednesday after a 2 1/2-year-long study of the impacts existing offshore wind projects have on fish and marine mammals.
The goal was to solidify existing knowledge of the impacts and call for further research in many areas.
NOAA and BOEM are among agencies that say there is no link between offshore wind preparation and whale deaths. Their co-authorship of a report detailing potential negative impacts on fish and marine mammals may intensify an already highly politicized controversy.i
Asked Friday about the likelihood of this happening, NOAA spokesperson Lauren Gaches reiterated the agency's position that offshore wind is not causing the whale deaths, which remain under investigation.
“We will also continue to explore how sound, vessel, and other human activities in the marine environment impact whales and other marine mammals,” she said.
The fishing industry is concerned that fish near construction sites may be killed or chased away for prolonged periods even after the turbines are built, according to the report.
“Physical changes associated with (offshore wind) developments will affect the marine environment — and, subsequently, the species that live there — to varying degrees,” the report read. ”These include construction and operation noise and vibration, electromagnetic fields, and thermal radiation from cables, as well as secondary gear entanglement.
In an interview, Fiona Hogan, research director for the Responsible Offshore Development Alliance, said: "We wanted to document what was known and not known. As far as we know, this is the first cooperatively developed report that cites all aspects of the potential interactions between fisheries and offshore wind.”
The alliance is a fishing industry group trying to improve the compatibility of offshore wind with fishing operations.
George R. Scocca
george@nyangler.com
www.nyangler.com - Your Secret Spot Online !
CommodoreOriginal Crew5,174 postsSince 2018
captmike28
Although I strongly disagree with the majority of what Newsday prints, I still read it on occasion just to stay on top of where the current battle lines are drawn.

Yesterday's 2 main features on Climate Change really pushed my buttons once again. The cover and major 2 page spread was filled with all kinds of "fear mongering projections" on what "could happen" to LI i the next 10, 20 50, 100 years if we do not bow down to the "climate religion" immediately!

I acknowledge the science of meteorology has made some significant improvements int he last century. Still, with even the best computer models, the forecasts we receive for the weather patterns approaching us in the next 3-10 days are frequently off by a huge amount. But we are supposed to believe that their computer models for stuff that will happen decades in the future is "dead nuts on"!

And another common thread to all those who believe in the "climate change religion" is that no matter what happens with our weather patterns it always spells "doom and gloom" unless we help the latest politically and greedy minded people/governments move in the direction that benefits them most financially. We should forget about the fact that there are other sources of "clean energy" like natural gas or nuclear because this does not benefit the "connected class"!

Case in point was the article about the small inlet that was formed in Belport Bay during Hurricane Sandy. First we are supposed to be frightened about the rising sea levels,. Then we are thrilled at how it cleaned up the bay and brought back many challenged species, Now we are supposed to be scared again because this small inlet is filling in. It doesn't seem to matter if there is atmospheric change occurring for the better or worse, we humans are always the cause of all of these problems!

Tiese like this remind me of a classic comedy bit done by George Carlin back in 1992 on "Saving the Planet". It is often played on the radio by one of our mor popular conversative talk show hosts. Essentially Carlin is pointing out the Earth is a "self-correcting" ecosystem and there is little man can do to totally destroy it.

Am I advocating for completely unrestricted pollution and disregard of our environment? Of course not. But there seems to be far too little actual research and real long term historical trends considered when it comes to the politics of "Climate Change'.

Its sad to think how many of our citizens are so totally oblivious to the constant barrage of propaganda shoved in their faces when it comes to this issue. How people can actually believe that politicians in DC or any other government for that matter can actually change the weather is the most frightening aspect to me. I really hope we can wake up before it is too late.

Enough "Tilting at Windmills" for today!
CaptainOriginal Crew1,853 postsSince 2018
OVERBORED
Like you read my mind.

Great post!
"Chance only favors the prepared mind" - Pasteur
Captain4,161 postsSince 2021
Roccus7
Roccus7MODnoreaster.com2023#331
Case in point was the article about the small inlet that was formed in Belport Bay during Hurricane Sandy. First we are supposed to be frightened about the rising sea levels,. Then we are thrilled at how it cleaned up the bay and brought back many challenged species, Now we are supposed to be scared again because this small inlet is filling in. It doesn't seem to matter if there is atmospheric change occurring for the better or worse, we humans are always the cause of all of these problems!
Classic example of "Climatologists" not having a clue about geology , and the hubris of man who assumes he can control barrier beaches...
Shall I go to heaven or a-fishing? - H. D. Thoreau
Veni. Vidi. Cepi. - with apologies to Gaius Julius Caesar
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,717 postsSince 2018
movetheboat
When people say save the Planet, they really mean mankind. Man is but a pimple on the ass of the Earth and we will be long gone while the Earth continues on. 95%? OF ALL THE SPECIES ever on the Earth are gone and homo sapiens will join that list one day. So why save anything including WHALES when destiny already has all species on the endangered list from day ONE!! The EARTH WILL CHEW US UP AND SPIT US OUT!! Then some other species will be dominant and maybe think they are something special and created by some type of superior almighty being.
CommodoreOriginal Crew12,530 postsSince 2018
captmike28
When people say save the Planet, they really mean mankind. Man is but a pimple on the ass of the Earth and we will be long gone while the Earth continues on. 95%? OF ALL THE SPECIES ever on the Earth are gone and homo sapiens will join that list one day. So why save anything including WHALES when destiny already has all species on the endangered list from day ONE!! The EARTH WILL CHEW US UP AND SPIT US OUT!! Then some other species will be dominant and maybe think they are something special and created by some type of superior almighty being.
Sounds like you lifted some of the key points George Carlin was stating during his classic comedy bit. It's all good when we are trying to educate others.

Carlin was both very funny and a bit of prophet at the same time!
CaptainOriginal Crew1,853 postsSince 2018
movetheboat
Sounds like you lifted some of the key points George Carlin was stating during his classic comedy bit. It's all good when we are trying to educate others.

Carlin was both very funny and a bit of prophet at the same time!
YES That Carlin piece was classic
CommodoreOriginal Crew12,530 postsSince 2018
jpd
jpdMODnoreaster.com2023#335
Noise in the ocean disrupts marine life - who knew? 🙁

www.businessinsider.com

New propellers with looped blades could help make the oceans quiet again, sparing both marine life and the climate

Quieter propulsion systems could save marine life from the deadly drone of boats overhead. They could be more fuel efficient, too.
www.businessinsider.com www.businessinsider.com
A lawyer with his briefcase can steal more than a hundred men with guns- Mario Puzo
CommodoreOriginal Crew9,876 postsSince 2018
WhatKnot
WhatKnotFREE2023#336
Deflection
Be Safe
CommodoreOriginal Crew12,915 postsSince 2019
wader
waderFREE2023#337
interesting article concerning a massive dolphin kill in the Black Sea being blamed on sonar - they think the kill may well be more then 1000 - but this type of activity off our East Coast is having no effect(?)
🙄

www.yahoo.com

More than 100 dolphins feared dead in Black Sea due to war in Ukraine, scientist says

Dolphins as casualties: The environmental costs of Ukraine .
www.yahoo.com www.yahoo.com
"Well, it's alright.
.............even if you're old and gray."
"Well, it's alright.
............you still got something to say."
AdmiralOriginal Crew20,900 postsSince 2018
jpd
jpdMODnoreaster.com2023#338
A lawyer with his briefcase can steal more than a hundred men with guns- Mario Puzo
CommodoreOriginal Crew9,876 postsSince 2018
Roccus7
Roccus7MODnoreaster.com2023#339
We had one on Friday, and they're bending over backwards saying it wasn't because of sonar activity...

Shall I go to heaven or a-fishing? - H. D. Thoreau
Veni. Vidi. Cepi. - with apologies to Gaius Julius Caesar
AdmiralOriginal Crew21,717 postsSince 2018
jpd
jpdMODnoreaster.com2023#340
nypost.com

Four whales die in 4 days: Wind farms creating ‘death zone’ at sea says ex-Greenpeace boss

Patrick Moore, a former Greenpeace leader, says work on wind turbines may well be to blame for surging whale deaths, including four minkes last week.
nypost.com nypost.com
A lawyer with his briefcase can steal more than a hundred men with guns- Mario Puzo
CommodoreOriginal Crew9,876 postsSince 2018

Sign in to reply to this thread.

Thread
Do they think we're idiots!
Sign in